- Open Access
Expiratory automatic endotracheal tube compensation reduces dynamic hyperinflation in a physical lung model
Critical Care volume 13, Article number: R4 (2009)
The effect of expiratory endotracheal tube (ETT) resistance on dynamic lung inflation is unknown. We hypothesized that ETT resistance causes dynamic lung hyperinflation by impeding lung emptying. We further hypothesized that compensation for expiratory ETT resistance by automatic tube compensation (ATC) attenuates dynamic lung hyperinflation.
A ventilator equipped with the original ATC mode and operating in a pressure-targeted mode was connected to a physical lung model that consists of four equally sized glass bottles filled with copper wool. Inspiratory pressure, peak expiratory flow, trapped lung volume and intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) were assessed at combinations of four inner ETT diameters (7.0, 7.5, 8.0 and 8.5 mm), four respiratory rates (15, 20, 25 and 30/minute), three inspiratory pressures (3.0, 4.5 and 6.0 cmH2O) and four lung compliances (113, 86, 58 and 28 ml/cmH2O). Intrinsic PEEP was measured at the end of an expiratory hold manoeuvre.
At a given test lung compliance, inspiratory pressure and ETT size, increasing respiratory rates from 15 to 30/minutes had the following effects: inspiratory tidal volume and peak expiratory flow were decreased by means of 25% (range 0% to 51%) and 11% (8% to 12%), respectively; and trapped lung volume and intrinsic PEEP were increased by means of 25% (0% to 51%) and 26% (5% to 45%), respectively (all P < 0.025). At otherwise identical baseline conditions, introduction of expiratory ATC significantly attenuated (P < 0.025), by approximately 50%, the respiratory rate-dependent decreases in inspiratory tidal volume and the increases in trapped lung volume and intrinsic PEEP.
In a lung model of pressure-targeted ventilation, expiratory ETT resistance caused dynamic lung hyperinflation during increases in respiratory rates, thereby reducing inspiratory tidal volume. Expiratory ATC attenuated these adverse effects.
In tracheally intubated and mechanically ventilated patients, expiratory resistance of an endotracheal tube (ETT) or a tracheostomy tube can cause dynamic lung hyperinflation by impeding lung emptying . Dynamic hyperinflation will successively either reduce tidal volume (during some forms of pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation ) or increase inspiratory plateau pressure (during volume-targeted mechanical ventilation) until a new steady state is reached [3–5]. Thus far, detailed knowledge on the contribution made by the mechanical properties of the ETT to dynamic lung hyperinflation and its ventilatory consequences during pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation is lacking.
Automatic tube compensation (ATC) is an auxiliary ventilatory mode that compensates for the flow-dependent, nonlinear pressure decrease across the ETT during inspiration and expiration . By facilitating lung emptying, expiratory ATC can be expected to counteract the ETT-induced dynamic lung hyperinflation. The original ATC system is equipped with a negative pressure source (generating up to 20 cmH2O of subatmospheric pressure). In combination with positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) it is used to compensate for expiratory ETT resistance. By contrast, in the commercially available ATC systems, expiratory ETT resistance is either not compensated for or its compensation is restricted to lowering the PEEP level down to zero pressure during expiration . It must be emphasized that expiratory ATC is effective only when it is used in the original mode .
The aim of this study was to assess the ETT-related effects on dynamic lung hyperinflation during pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation in the absence and presence of expiratory tube compensation using the original ATC mode. We hypothesized that ATC would be able to counteract the ETT-related effects on dynamic lung hyperinflation. For this purpose, we used a physical lung model to simulate a wide range of ventilatory situations. In addition, we used a mathematical model of passive expiration to exclude the dynamic effects introduced by the mechanical properties of the ventilator's pneumatic components.
Materials and methods
The experimental set-up is shown in Figure 1. The lung model is in agreement with the ISO 5369 (1987) standards. To simulate different lung compliances, four equally sized glass bottles of 25 l volume each were filled with copper wool (to ensure isothermal volume changes) and connected in parallel by a distribution header. Manual one-way valves in each of the four connecting tubes allowed ventilation of one, two, three or four bottles, resulting in approximate compliances of 25, 50, 75 and 100 ml/cmH2O. The distribution header was connected to an artificial trachea consisting of a transparent tube of 21 mm inner diameter (ID) . The ETT under investigation was introduced into the artificial trachea. At its proximal end, the ETT was connected via a standard 15-mm bent swivel connector (Portex 100/250/001; Portex Ltd, Hythe, Kent, UK) to the Y-piece and the tubing system of an original ATC ventilator.
Theoretical concept and technical details of the original ATC ventilator, as well as differences from commercially available ATC systems, were previously reported in detail [6, 7]. For the purposes of this study, the original ATC system was modified to allow expiratory hold manoeuvres. These manoeuvres were manually initiated but automatically synchronized with the ventilator's flow pattern (the manoeuvres started shortly before the beginning of the next inspiration).
Flow was measured using a Fleisch No. 2 pneumotachograph (Metabo, Epalinges, Switzerland) connected to a differential pressure transducer (CPS 1; Hoffrichter, Schwerin, Germany). Airway pressure (Paw) was measured via a separate opening located in the wall of the connecting diffuser of the pneumotachograph. Tracheal pressure (Ptrach) in the artificial trachea was determined via a ring channel located beyond the region of flow separation at 60 mm below the tip of the ETT . Paw and Ptrach were measured with pressure transducers (1210A; ICSensors Inc., Milpitas, CA, USA). Flow and pressure signals were sampled at a rate of 100 Hz and digitized at 12 bits for subsequent analysis.
The experimental methods were approved by the local Institutional Review Board. The investigations were performed under room air (21% oxygen) during pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation using the biphasic positive airway pressure mode with an inspiratory to expiratory time ratio of 1.0, a PEEP of 5 cmH2O and a pressure rise time of 0.2 seconds. We alternated the upper inspiratory pressure limits at 8.0, 9.5 and 11 cmH2O, resulting in inspiratory driving pressures (the difference between the upper pressure limit and PEEP) of 3.0, 4.5 and 6.0 cmH2O, respectively. We used respiratory rates of 15, 20, 25 and 30 breaths/minute. Test lung compliances were varied by ventilating one, two, three or four of the glass bottles. ETTs (Hi-Lo Evac; Mallinckrodt Laboratories, Athlone, Ireland) of four different IDs (7.0, 7.5, 8.0, and 8.5 mm) were tested.
The different test combinations (consisting of four ETT IDs, four respiratory rates, three inspiratory pressures, and four test lung compliances) were investigated in random order, first in the absence then in the presence of ATC. We also performed the interventions in the absence of any ETT. This enabled us to assess the degree of respiratory rate-dependent dynamic hyperinflation unrelated to the mechanical properties of an ETT, and to judge the extent of ATC in absolute terms by comparing the degree of dynamic hyperinflation during ATC with that in the absence of an ETT. In these cases, the pneumotachograph was directly connected to the artificial trachea.
After steady-state conditions had been reached, the expiratory hold manoeuvre was started. The manoeuvre was terminated once Ptrach had levelled off but had been maintained for at least 10 seconds. Intrinsic PEEP was defined as peak Ptrach minus PEEP within the final 100 ms of the expiratory hold manoeuvre. Ventilatory volumes, intrinsic PEEP and other ventilatory variables were determined in the absence and presence of ATC, and in the absence of any ETT. The tidal volume generated under static conditions is referred to as the 'ideal tidal volume', and it was calculated as the product of compliance and peak inspiratory pressure. The difference between ideal and measured tidal volume constitutes the dynamically trapped volume (Vtrapped.dyn). All measured volumes were standardized to standard temperature pressure dry (STPD) conditions. Data obtained during 5 to 10 ventilatory cycles under steady-state conditions just before the start of the hold manoeuvre were stored for subsequent analysis.
Because the ventilator's expiratory valve and volume acceleration/deceleration phenomena during respiratory cycling may modify the findings to an unknown extent, we additionally assessed the effects of the various interventions in greater detail in a mathematical model of passive expiration [see Additional data file 1]. In this context, the influence of the respiratory rate and the inspiratory to expiratory time ratio was assessed by examining the expiratory cycle time (Tex).
Differences between the test conditions – no ETT in place, ETT without ATC, and ETT with ATC (group variable) – at identical test conditions were assessed by one-way analysis of variance. If analysis of variance revealed a significant difference, then Tukey's pair-wise multiple comparisons test was performed for subsequent identification of group differences. A two-tailed P value below 0.025 was regarded the limit of significance. All data are presented as mean ± standard deviation.
With one, two, three or four glass bottles connected, compliances of the test lung were 29 ± 2, 58 ± 2, 86 ± 4 and 113 ± 5 ml/cmH2O, respectively. At these compliances, the respective calculated ideal tidal volumes varied with the inspiratory pressures above PEEP. Respective ideal tidal volumes were 88 ± 3, 172 ± 6, 257 ± 15 and 343 ± 15 ml at an inspiratory pressure of 3.0 cmH2O; 129 ± 7, 260 ± 10, 388 ± 13 and 509 ± 16 ml at an inspiratory pressure of 4.5 cmH2O; and 170 ± 11, 345 ± 13, 519 ± 16 and 674 ± 24 ml at an inspiratory pressure of 6.0 cmH2O. At a flow rate of 1 l/second, resistance of the test lung and the ventilator circuit (without the ETT) were constant at 5.1 cmH2O·s/l.
The principal effects of ATC are captured in original tracings of airflow, volume and airway and tracheal pressures (Figure 2). Compared with no ATC, compensation for expiratory ETT resistance by ATC increased tidal volume and decreased Ptrach to the level of external PEEP, reflecting reduced intrinsic PEEP and therefore reduced dynamic hyperinflation. ATC did not affect peak Ptrach, peak inspiratory pressure or PEEP.
At ETT sizes of 7.0 and 8.5 mm ID, the respiratory rate-induced decreases in tidal volume were significantly less in the presence than in the absence of expiratory ATC (P < 0.025; Figure 3). Findings were comparable for ETT sizes 7.5 and 8.0 mm ID (data not shown). In agreement with these findings, when increasing respiratory rates from 15 to 30/minute at a lung compliance of 113 ml/cmH2O, an ETT size of 7.0 mm ID and peak inspiratory pressures of 3.0, 4.5 and 6.0 cmH2O, the corresponding peak expiratory flows were approximately twice as high, and intrinsic PEEP and dynamically trapped volume were approximately twice as low in the presence compared with the absence of expiratory ATC (Table 1). Under otherwise identical conditions, the effects of ATC on the various ventilatory variables were qualitatively similar but increasingly less pronounced at lung compliances of 89 and 58 ml/cmH2O. At a test lung compliance of 29 ml/cmH2O, ATC did not exhibit any significant effect (data not shown).
During expiratory ATC at the lower respiratory rates and inspiratory pressures, actual tidal volumes were slightly but significantly (P < 0.025) larger than the calculated ideal tidal volumes (maximally 31 and 37 ml with the use of ETTs of 7.0 mm and 8.5 mm ID, respectively; Figure 3).
Computation in the mathematical model showed that at a given expiratory cycle time (Tex) reduction in tidal volume (as an indicator of dynamic hyperinflation) must be expected to worsen with increasing compliance, increasing resistance and decreasing ID of the ETT (Figure 4). This adverse effect on tidal volume can be expected to be attenuated by expiratory ATC.
The main findings of this in vitro investigation can be summarized as follows. First, with an ETT in place, tidal volumes decreased, and intrinsic PEEP and trapped volume increased in a respiratory rate-dependent manner under all experimental conditions. Second, expiratory ATC blunted the respiratory rate-dependent decreases in tidal volume, and the increases in intrinsic PEEP and trapped volume at all three inspiratory pressures, four ETT internal diameters and at three of the four compliances studied. Finally, the efficacy of expiratory ATC decreased with decreasing compliances. In agreement with these findings in the physical lung model, the mathematical model suggests that efficacy of expiratory ATC can be expected to be highest at normal to high lung compliance, low airway resistance and small ETT size. The findings confirm our hypothesis that expiratory ATC would counteract ETT-related adverse effects on dynamic lung hyperinflation.
Pulmonary hyperinflation is defined as an increase in the functional residual capacity above normal . It can be quantified in terms of volume (trapped volume) or pressure (intrinsic PEEP). Various conditions can promote pulmonary hyperinflation, most of them being related to the mechanical properties of the patient's respiratory system and/or the ventilator settings. For example, pulmonary hyperinflation may result from loss of lung recoil (as in emphysema) and/or dynamic hyperinflation. The latter, in turn, may be caused by reduced expiratory flow (as with increased airway resistance) and/or insufficient duration of expiration (Tex) required for complete lung emptying. Tex, in turn, depends on respiratory rate and inspiratory to expiratory time ratio. Furthermore, lung emptying also depends on the preceding inspiratory volume, and thus on inspiratory driving pressure and the respiratory system's compliance.
To our knowledge, this is the first study that focuses on the effect of expiratory ETT resistance on dynamic hyperinflation and its ventilatory consequences during pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation. This is of considerable clinical relevance because the ETT-related ventilatory effects during mechanical ventilation are anything but trivial, with up to 50% reduction in tidal volume due to expiratory ETT resistance, as demonstrated in the present investigation. Our findings suggest that expiratory ETT resistance may cause clinically relevant dynamic lung hyperinflation by impeding lung emptying. These ETT-related problems worsened with increasing respiratory rate, inspiratory to expiratory time ratio and lung compliance, and with decreasing airway resistance and ID of the ETT. We could demonstrate that the ETT-induced adverse ventilatory effects can be significantly attenuated if expiratory ETT resistance is compensated for by expiratory ATC. This intervention was most effective at normal to high lung compliance, low airway resistance and small ETT size. Our findings suggest that in addition to the known favourable effects of ATC in the spontaneously breathing patient [10–13], the ATC mode may also be advantageous in mechanically ventilated patients.
An expiratory support system using a computer-controlled piston pump as a negative pressure source to augment exhalation was recently proposed to avoid air trapping . This system works by matching expiratory (aspirated) and inspiratory (delivered) volumes, aiming to preserve the exponential shape of the expiratory flow pattern by using the entire duration of expiration. However, it requires knowledge of current mechanical properties (respiratory system compliance, respiratory system resistance, and resistance of the ETT). Because the system is designed to counteract increased expiratory resistance irrespective of its origin (caused by expiratory ETT resistance and/or airway resistance), subatmospheric pressure will be transmitted not only to the artificial airway but also to the lower airways. This carries a risk for airway collapse in susceptible patients (for instance, in those suffering from exacerbated chronic obstructive pulmonary disease). Furthermore, because the system works on matching expiratory and inspiratory volumes, an air leak may cause overcompensation and thus can lead to an inadequate fall in tracheal and possibly even in alveolar pressure. Thus far, the system has only been bench tested. By contrast, the ATC system has been extensively tested in humans. In addition, because compensation is targeted at ETT resistance and not at airway resistance, the ATC mode prevents Ptrach from decreasing below the preset PEEP level  (Figure 2). Furthermore, knowledge of current respiratory system compliance and resistance is not required, because ATC is based on Ptrach, which is derived from the ETT-specific coefficients and the continuously measured Paw and airflow rate [6, 8].
Our findings indicate that the detrimental effects of expiratory ETT resistance on lung emptying should become clinically relevant with increasing compliance, decreasing airway resistance, decreasing ETT size and decreasing Tex (the latter being a function of respiratory rate and inspiratory to expiratory time ratio). The combination of high respiratory rates and short expiratory times is observed in patients with the acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). If these patients are ventilated with high respiratory rates and tidal volumes (or peak inspiratory pressures) at the upper level of acceptance , then Tex may become too short to allow complete lung emptying despite high expiratory flow rates, because of low lung compliance in ARDS. In such situation, compensation for expiratory ETT resistance by expiratory ATC may be a suitable means of facilitating lung emptying. Whereas our mathematical model would support such an assumption in general (Figure 4, upper panels), the physical lung model study showed a lack of efficacy of expiratory ATC at very low lung compliances. This apparent contradiction is best explained by the finite efficacy of real compared with ideal expiratory ETT compensation .
The problems associated with ETT-induced increased expiratory resistance are not necessarily restricted to patients with diseased lungs during controlled ventilation, but can equally be expected in patients with normal lung mechanics requiring high respiratory rates (for instance, because of increased ventilatory demand), as may be the case during assisted spontaneous breathing (for example, during pressure support ventilation). The high respiratory rates then will result in a close to 1:1 inspiratory to expiratory time ratio. In such cases, dynamic lung hyperinflation may be more the rule than the exception. Incomplete lung emptying during pressure support ventilation will increase inspiratory airway pressures (rather than decrease tidal volume as during pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation), possibly leading to patient-ventilator asynchrony by futile inspiratory efforts .
At first glance, patients with exacerbated chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) should also benefit from expiratory ATC. However, increased airway resistance in such patients will mostly exceed the resistive properties of the ETT. Based on this and on our findings in the mathematical model (Figure 4, middle panels), it is therefore unlikely that such patients will benefit from expiratory ATC.
This study carries the obvious limitations of any bench study. The data were acquired in physical and mathematical lung models. Measurements were made at constant compliances, thereby excluding intratidal nonlinearity of compliance, which may be present in patients with severe pulmonary disease. Similarly, the effect of regional imbalances in lung mechanics with parallel heterogeneity in time constants and airway stiffness could not be assessed. Thus, caution must be exercised when applying the findings to clinical practice.
Statistically significant but clinically negligible increases in tidal volume above those denoted as ideal were observed during expiratory ATC, predominantly at low respiratory rates and small tidal volumes. They reflect a slight overshoot of the ATC controller during tight ETT compensation, which is, however, of little if any clinical relevance [7, 13].
Differences in the effects of the various interventions on ventilatory variables in the presence (with expiratory ATC) of an ETT and in the absence (by necessity without expiratory ATC) of an ETT indicate that, although expiratory ATC clearly attenuated the adverse effects of expiratory ETT resistance, it is (not yet) able to counteract this resistance fully [7, 10].
High expiratory ETT resistance can cause dynamic hyperinflation, which in turn will reduce inspiratory tidal volume under most forms of pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation. These ETT-related side effects are markedly attenuated by expiratory ATC.
Resistance of the ETT during expiration can markedly impede lung emptying, worsening with increasing respiratory rate and lung compliance, and with decreasing airway resistance and ETT size.
Under most forms of pressure-targeted mechanical ventilation, the ETT-related effects on lung emptying are inevitably associated with reduction in the inspiratory tidal volume of up to 50%.
Compensation for expiratory tube resistance by the (original) ATC mode is a highly attractive way to minimize ETT-related impairment of lung emptying.
In contrast to existing commercially available ATC systems, only the original ATC system is equipped with a negative pressure source that, in combination with PEEP, compensates for expiratory ETT resistance.
automatic tube compensation
positive end-expiratory pressure
expiratory cycle time.
Guttmann J, Eberhard L, Fabry B, Bertschmann W, Zeravik J, Adolph M, Eckart J, Wolff G: Time constant/volume relationship of passive expiration in mechanically ventilated ARDS patients. Eur Respir J 1995, 8: 114-120. 10.1183/09031936.95.08010114
Imanaka H, Kacmarek RM, Ritz R, Hess D: Tracheal gas insufflation: pressure control versus volume control ventilation. A lung model study. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996, 153: 1019-1024.
Marini J, Ravenscraft S: Mean airway pressure: physiologic determinants and clinical importance: Part I: physiologic determinants and measurements. Clinical implications. Crit Care Med 1992, 20: 1461-1472.
Marini J, Ravenscraft S: Mean airway pressure: physiologic determinants and clinical importance: Part II: Clinical implications. Crit Care Med 1992, 20: 1604-1616. 10.1097/00003246-199211000-00020
Marini J, Crooke P, Truwit J: Determinants and limits of pressure preset ventilation: a mathematical model of pressure control. J Appl Physiol 1989, 67: 1081-1092.
Fabry B, Guttmann J, Eberhard L, Wolff G: Automatic compensation of endotracheal tube resistance in spontaneously breathing patients. Technol Health Care 1994, 1: 281-291.
Elsasser S, Guttmann J, Stocker R, Mols G, Haberthür C: Accuracy of automatic tube compensation (ATC) in new-generation mechanical ventilators. Crit Care Med 2003, 31: 2619-2626. 10.1097/01.CCM.0000094224.78718.2A
Guttmann J, Eberhard L, Fabry B, Bertschmann W, Wolff G: Continuous calculation of intratracheal pressure in tracheally intubated patients. Anesthesiology 1993, 79: 503-513. 10.1097/00000542-199309000-00014
Agostoni E, Mead J: Statics of the respiratory system. In The Respiratory System: Mechanics of Breathing. Handbook of Physiology. Volume II. Edited by: Macklem PT, Mead J. Bethesda, MD: American Physiological Society; 1964:387-409.
Guttmann J, Haberthür C, Mols G: Automatic tube compensation (ATC). In Closed-loop Control Mechanical Ventilation. Respiratory Care Clinics of North America. Volume 7. Edited by: Iotti GA (guest). Philadelphia, PA: Saunders; 2001:475-501.
Fabry B, Haberthür C, Zappe D, Guttmann J, Kuhlen R, Stocker R: Breathing pattern and additional work of breathing in spontaneously breathing patients with different ventilatory demands during inspiratory pressure support and automatic tube compensation. Intensive Care Med 1997, 23: 545-552. 10.1007/s001340050371
Haberthür C, Fabry B, Stocker R, Ritz R, Guttmann J: Additional inspiratory work of breathing imposed by tracheostomy tubes and non-ideal ventilator properties in critically ill patients. Intensive Care Med 1999, 25: 514-519. 10.1007/s001340050890
Haberthür C, Mols G, Elsasser S, Bingisser R, Stocker R, Guttmann J: Extubation after breathing trials with automatic tube compensation, T-tube, or pressure support ventilation. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2002, 46: 973-979. 10.1034/j.1399-6576.2002.460808.x
Uchiyama A, Nishimura M, Amata M, Mashimo T, Fujino Y: A new expiratory support system for resolving air trapping in lungs during mechanical ventilation: a lung model study. Technol Health Care 2007, 15: 213-220.
The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network: Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med 2000, 342: 1301-1308. 10.1056/NEJM200005043421801
Fabry B, Guttmann J, Eberhard L, Bauer T, Haberthür C, Wolff G: An analysis of desynchronisation between the spontaneously breathing patient and ventilator during inspiratory pressure support. Chest 1995, 107: 1387-1394. 10.1378/chest.107.5.1387
The physical test lung was partly supported by grants from Fresenius-Kabi (Switzerland) and Carbamed (Switzerland). SS, KM and JG were supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, grant # GU/6-1.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
CH designed the study and drafted the manuscript. AM performed measurements in the physical lung model. JS and HJP participated in manuscript drafting. SS ran analyses on the mathematical lung model. KM performed statistical analysis. JG designed the mathematical lung model. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: Word document providing a detailed description of the mathematical lung model for passive expiration. (DOC 126 KB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Haberthür, C., Mehlig, A., Stover, J.F. et al. Expiratory automatic endotracheal tube compensation reduces dynamic hyperinflation in a physical lung model. Crit Care 13, R4 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1186/cc7693
- Tidal Volume
- Inspiratory Pressure
- Exacerbate Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
- Lung Compliance
- Dynamic Hyperinflation