Balloon laryngoscopy reduces head extension and blade leverage in patients with potential cervical spine injury
© Current Science Ltd 2000
Received: 6 May 1999
Accepted: 29 October 1999
Published: 24 January 2000
Head extension and excessive laryngoscope blade levering motion(LBLM) are undesirable during airway management of trauma patients. Wehypothesized that laryngoscopy with a modified blade facilitating glotticexposure by balloon inflation would reduce head extension and LBLM.
Patients and methods
Seventeen elective surgery patients were enrolled. Patients laysupine with their heads flat on a rigid board and had a rigid collar aroundtheir necks. Laryngoscopy was performed with the modified blade and a standardcurved blade. Head extension and LBLM angles were determined upon maximalglottic exposure and compared used paired t-tests. Laryngoscopic viewgrade and oxygen saturation were also determined.
Balloon laryngoscopy resulted in less head extension and LBLM(P <0.001). Laryngoscopic view was approximately identical withboth blades, and oxygen saturation was always above 97%.
Balloon laryngoscopy reduces head extension and LBLM undersimulated cervical spine precautions.
Keywordsballoon laryngoscopy blade extension head leverage spine
Cervical spine stabilization manoeuvres are employed during conventional airway management of trauma patients to avoid secondary neurological deficits [1,2,3,4,5]. A degree of potentially hazardous head extension may still be necessary for laryngeal visualization, however . Head and neck stabilization may prevent the alignment of mouth and glottis . Poor laryngeal visualization is frequently associated with excessive laryngoscope blade levering motion (LBLM) and subsequent risk of upper teeth or gum trauma .
In the present study, we performed laryngoscopy with a no. 4 standard and a no. 4 modified curved blade in elective surgery patients under simulated cervical spine precautions. The modified blade carries two no. 10 Foley catheters (Fig. 1) and is a partial development of a new laryngoscope (international patent document no. 98/19589) . The standard balloon laryngoscopy technique includes modified blade tip insertion into the vallecula, right catheter balloon inflation with 2ml air (Fig. 1) and blade elevation to achieve the best laryngeal view . In patients with anterior larynx, the lifting of the epiglottis is facilitated by establishing adequate contact between the inflated balloon's upper surface and the tongue base and hyoid bone .
We hypothesized that balloon laryngoscopy might result in less head extension and LBLM, because balloon inflation and subsequent blade elevation should facilitate laryngeal exposure and reduce the extent of the necessary laryngoscopic manoeuvres.
Patients and methods
Ethics committee approval and informed, written patient consent were obtained. The enrollees were adult males, classified as American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status I, and were scheduled for elective surgery that required general anaesthesia with endotracheal intubation. Exclusion criteria were a history of cervical spine pathology, any condition predisposing to pulmonary aspiration and previous difficult intubation . All patients had Mallampati class I oropharyngeal views , head extension was greater than 35° , thyromental distance was greater than 6.5 cm , sternomental distance was greater than 13.5 cm , maximal incisal opening was greater then 4 cm  and body mass index was less than 27.5 kg/m2.
The operating table was kept parallel to the operating room floor (defined as horizontal plane) as follows: an automatic angle finder (serial no 295; Fisher Instruments, Kent, UK), detached from its metallic ruler (Fig. 1), was sequentially placed on the right-long and cephalad-short sides of the table's metallic frame; and each time the table's inclination was adjusted until the angle finder read 0°.
Patients lay supine with their heads flat on the operating table. Before induction of anaesthesia, a piece of adhesive tape (1.2×5cm) was placed on the right patient cheek with its median longitudinal axis parallel to the occlusal surface of the maxillary molars (or gums; Fig. 2). Standard monitoring (including pulse oximetry) was used.
After 5 min preoxygenation with 100% oxygen, anaesthesia was induced with fentanyl (2 μ g/kg) and propofol (2.5 mg/kg). After the disappearance of the eyelid reflex, a rigid board was placed under each patients' shoulders and occiput , and a rigid Philadelphia collar was fitted around their necks. Airway instrumentation was facilitated with intravenous succinylcholine (1.5 mg/kg). After the disappearance of the fasciculations in the face, the patient head was placed in the neutral position by aligning the occlusal surface of the maxillary molars' perpendicular to the operating table as follows: the angle finder's 'vertical arm' (Fig. 1) was placed on the longitudinal axis of the adhesive tape (Fig. 2), and the head was manipulated until the angle finder read 0°. Subsequently, laryngoscopy was performed with both standard and modified blades in randomized order. In between laryngoscopies, neutral head position was resumed.
Balloon laryngoscopy technique consisted of modified blade tip insertion into the vallecula, right catheter balloon inflation with 2 ml air, and blade elevation until maximal glottic exposure was achieved. The angles of the laryngoscope handle and the maxillary molars' occlusal surface relative to horizontal (Fig. 3; angles â1 and â2, respectively) were measured with the angle finder upon maximal glottic exposure with each blade. To measure the angle of the handle relative to horizontal, the angle finder's metallic ruler was placed on the median longitudinal axis of the handle's posterior aspect. All patients were intubated during the second laryngoscopy immediately after measurements were taken.
Airway instrumentation was performed by a senior anesthesiologist (MPB), who had a prior experience of more than 200 balloon laryngoscopies. The measured angles, the best laryngoscopic view during each laryngoscopy and oxygen saturation throughout the study were recorded. The laryngoscopic view was graded with the use of a modified grading scale (Table 1) proposed by SDM and MJJ.
The difference '90°-â2' was defined as head extension angle, and the difference 'â1-â2' was defined as the LBLM angle. The LBLM angle (Fig. 3; angle â3) is formed between the occlusal surface axis of the maxillary molars or gums (Fig. 3; line OS) and a chord (Fig. 3; line CH) that is perpendicular to the axis of the handle (Fig. 3; line AH) and corresponds to the radian formed by the proximal one-third of the convex surface of the blade. This chord passes through the distal end point of the radian (Fig. 3; point E).
The maximal acceptable laryngoscopy duration and time between the two laryngoscopies were 30s, and the maximal allowable study procedure duration was 180s. Procedure timing began upon succinylcholine administration.
The modified Cormack-Lehane grading scale used to evaluate the laryngoscopic findings obtained in the present study
The anterior commissure of glottis is visible
More than 50% of glottis is visible; the anterior
commissure of glottis is not visible
Less than 50% of glottis is visible, including its
posterior commissure and the arytenoid cartilages
Only the arytenoid cartilages and the epiglottis are visible
Only the epiglottis is visible
Only the retropharyngeal wall is visible
Values of the head extension and laryngoscope blade levering motion angles during conventional and balloon laryngoscopy
Conventional Macintosh blade
Modified Macintosh blade
Angle of head extension
8.29 ± 1.57
4.91 ± 1.42
Angle of laryngoscope blade levering motion
10.76 ± 1.75
5.53 ± 2.13
In the current investigation, we determined the potentially beneficial effects of the use of a curved blade modified to improve laryngeal visualization by balloon inflation on the cervical spine motion and LBLM under simulated cervical spine precautions. The present data showed a 40-50% reduction in the head extension and LBLM angles with balloon laryngoscopy (Table 2). This might be due to reduced need to manoeuvre the modified blade while exposing the glottis.
The estimated incidence of difficult laryngoscopy [grade III b or less (Table 1)] in general surgery patients is approximately 1% . The use of neutral head position along with cervical spine stabilization manoeuvres has resulted in an incidence of 4.3–16.6% [2,15]. The 0% incidence in the current study may be due to the combined use of multiple difficult airway predictors during patient selection, and the relatively small patient number (n = 17). Additionally, the maintenance of oxygen saturation above 97% throughout the study procedure was to be expected, because the safe duration of apnea tolerance in non-obese, American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status I patients exceeds 4min .
It seemed sensible to compare head extension and LBLM angles only if laryngeal exposure was maximal and approximately identical during both laryngoscopies in all patients. Maximal values would then be achieved in both angles. If in some patients the larynx were partly (or not at all) exposed, the head extension would probably be less than if the full view were obtained . Consequently, the head extension angles would be falsely underestimated during the laryngoscopy with the least glottic exposure . The risk of this bias would increase in patients with predicted difficult laryngoscopy. In such patients, conventional laryngoscopy might result in lesser laryngeal exposure than is achieved with balloon laryngoscopy . Furthermore, the increased difficulty in laryngeal visualization might result in excessive LBLM  and subsequent overestimation of the 'conventional' LBLM angles. Thus, we studied patients with 'easy' airways in order to maximize the probability of obtaining satisfactory (grade II b or greater, Table 1) and similar laryngoscopic views with both blades.
External head extension angles during laryngoscopy with different blades and with or without cervical spine stabilization have been measured in two previous studies [2,3]. In the study by Hastings and Wood , the head extension angles for best laryngeal view during conventional laryngoscopy under manual head immobilization (mean ± standard deviation 9 ± 6 °) were similar to ours (Table 2). The smaller coefficient of variation (defined as standard deviation/mean value) of the present results (0.19 versus 0.67 ) may be due to the following: all laryngoscopies were performed by one experienced operator, whereas in the previous study  62 laryngoscopies were performed by 16 operators; and the use of a hard collar for cervical spine stabilization, which has eliminated the potential variability in angle measurements caused by differences in the force applied by different assistants performing head immobilization .
Head extension is the major external movement that occurs during airway management . Also, the externally measured head extension angle during laryngoscopy has been correlated with the angle formed between the occiput and the fourth cervical vertebra (r2 = 0.7) . The maximum allowable head extension during airway management of trauma victims and the actual risk of neurological deterioration associated with conventional airway management techniques applied in cervical spine-injured patients still remain to be determined, however.
In the current study, we also determined the LBLM, which has not been previously determined under simulated cervical spine precautions. LBLM was defined by SDM and MJJ as the backward motion of the blade's convex surface toward the maxilla. Its range was estimated by measuring the angle between the occlusal surface axis of the maxillary molars and the chord of the radian formed by the proximal one-third of the blade (Fig. 3). This chord is the best straight-line approximation to the geometrical shape of the proximal one-third of the blade's convex surface. This portion of the no. 4 blade is most frequently in close proximity with the upper teeth of adult males during laryngoscopy, and may traumatize them if excessive LBLM is employed. Upper incisor trauma and/or dislodgment may then result in aspiration of tooth fragments into the trachea.
In our opinion, the potential risks of spinal cord injury and of maxillary teeth dislodgement during laryngoscopy performed in trauma patients under cervical spine precautions should not be underestimated (especially in the presence of unstable cervical spine injuries and/or maxillary trauma), despite the fact that they have not yet been accurately determined.
In summary, we demonstrated that the head extension and LBLM angles are significantly reduced when balloon laryngoscopy is performed under simulated cervical spine precautions in carefully preselected and adequately anaesthetized and paralyzed elective surgery patients. Such 'ideal' conditions may not be achievable in the emergency setting, however. Thus, further investigation is required to prove the usefulness of balloon laryngoscopy in the emergency airway management of cervical spine-injured patients.
- Hastings RH, Marks JD: Airway management for trauma patients with potential cervical spine injuries. Anesth Analg. 1991, 73: 471-482.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hastings RH, Wood PR: Head extension and laryngeal view during larynoscopy with cervical spine stabilization maneuvers. Anesthesiology. 1994, 80: 825-831.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hastings RH, Vigil CA, Hanna R, Yang BY, Sartoris DJ: Cervical spine movement during laryngoscopy with the Bullard, Macintosh, and Miller laryngoscopes. Anesthesiology. 1995, 82: 859-869. 10.1097/00000542-199504000-00007.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Watts ADJ, Gelb AW, Bach DB, Pelz DM: Comparison of the Bullard and Macintosh laryngoscopes for endotracheal intubation of patients with a potential cervical spine injury. Anesthesiology. 1997, 87: 1335-1342. 10.1097/00000542-199712000-00012.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Majernick T, Bieniek R, Houston J, Hughes H: Cervical spine movement during orotracheal intubation. Ann Emerg Med. 1986, 15: 417-420.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- McCoy EP, Mirachur RK: The levering laryngoscope. Anaesthesia. 1993, 48: 516-519.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mentzelopoulos SD, Ballas CJ: Laryngoscope with a flexible blade, inflatable balloons, two thin double lumen tubes, and one thin single lumen tube. International patent document No. 98/19589; International Application No. PCT/GR97/00038 published under the Patent Cooperation Treaty.Google Scholar
- Mentzelopoulos SD, Tsitsika MV, Karamichali EA: Difficult airway management with balloon inflation. Anesth Analg. 1999, 88: 1425-1426.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mallampati SR, Gatt SP, Gugino LD, et al: A clinical sign to predict difficult tracheal intubation: a prospective study. Can J Anaesth. 1985, 32: 429-434.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Benumof JL: Management of the difficult adult airway: with special emphasis on awake tracheal intubation. Anesthesiology . 1991, 75: 1087-1110.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ramadhani SAL, Mohamed LA, Rocke DA, Gows E: Sternomental distance as the sole predictor of difficult laryngoscopy in obstetric anaesthesia. Br J Anaesth. 1996, 77: 312-316.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sheppard IM, Sheppard FM: Maximal incisal opening: a diagnostic index. J Dent Med. 1965, 20: 13-15.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Morgan GE, Mikhail MS: Anesthesia for patients with endocrine disease. In: Clinical Anesthesiology, 2nd ed. Edited by Reinhardt S, Langan C. New Jersey: Appleton and Lange. 1996, 645-646.Google Scholar
- El-Ganzouri RA, McCarthy JR, Tuman JK, Tanck NE, Ivankovich DA: Preoperative airway assessment: predictive value of a multivariate risk index. Anesth Analg. 1996, 82: 1197-1204.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Suderman VS, Crosby ET, Lui A: Elective oral tracheal intubation in cervical spine-injured adults. Can J Anaesth. 1991, 38: 785-789.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jense HG, Dubin SA, Silverstein PI: Effect of obesity on safe duration of apnea in anesthetized humans. Anesth Analg. 1991, 72: 89-93.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar