Skip to main content

Table 2 Subsequent multicenter randomized trials and their mortality findings

From: Positive single-center randomized trials and subsequent multicenter randomized trials in critically ill patients: a systematic review

sRCT

References of mRCT

Number of patients

Number of centers

Number of countries

Mortality

Anti-lipopolysaccharide immunotherapy in sepsis, 1984 [14]

Greenman et al. [37]

486

33

1

No statistically significant difference

Angus et al. [26]

1102

136

1

No statistically significant difference

Interpose abdominal counterpulsation during cardiac arrest, 1992 [21]

Not available

    

Supranormal oxygen delivery, 1993 [8]

Not available

    

Terlipressin for upper gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic patients, 1995 [15]

Feu et al. [33]

161

4

1

No statistically significant difference

Escorsell et al. [32]

219

9

2

No statistically significant difference

Non-invasive ventilation in immunosuppressed patients, 2000 [7, 13]

Lemiale et al. [41]

374

28

2

No statistically significant difference

High-intensity renal replacement therapy in acute renal failure, 2000 [20]

Palevsky et al. [44]

1124

27

1

No statistically significant difference

Bellomo et al. [29]

1508

35

2

No statistically significant difference

Early goal-directed therapy in sepsis, 2001 [19]

Peake et al. [45]

1600

51

5

No statistically significant difference

Yealy et al. [49]

1341

31

1

No statistically significant difference

Mouncey et al. [42]

1260

56

1

No statistically significant difference

Intensive insulin therapy, 2001 [23]

Finfer et al. [34]

6104

42

4

Statistically significant mortality increase at 90 days (28% vs. 25%)

Amiodarone in refractory ventricular fibrillation, 2002 [11]

Kudenchuk et al. [40]

3026

10a

2

No statistically significant difference

Daily hemodialysis in acute renal failure, 2002 [22]

Ponce et al. [47]

407

2

1

No statistically significant difference

Hemofiltration versus peritoneal dialysis in acute renal failure, 2002 [18]

Not available

    

Selective decontamination of digestive tract, 2003 [9]

de Smet et al. [30]

5939

13

1

No statistically significant difference

Myburgh et al. [43]

5982

19

1

No statistically significant difference

Charcoal in poisoning, 2003 [10]

Eddleston et al. [31]

4632

3

1

No statistically significant difference

Epinephrine during cardiopulmonary resuscitation, 2009 [17]

Perkins et al. [46]

8014

5b

1

Statistically significant mortality reduction at 30 days (3.2% vs 2.4%)

Beta blocker in sepsis, 2013 [16]

Kakihana et al. [39]

151

54

1

No statistically significant difference

Transfusion thresholds in upper gastrointestinal bleeding, 2013 [24]

Jairath et al. [38]

936

6

1

No statistically significant difference

Oxygen targets, 2016 [12]

Schjørring et al. [48]

2928

35

7

No statistically significant difference

Gelissen et al. [36]

574

4

1

No statistically significant difference

Timing of renal replacement therapy in acute kidney injury, 2016 [25]

Gaudry et al. [35]

620

31

1

No statistically significant difference

Barbar et al. [28]

488

29

1

No statistically significant difference

Bagshaw et al. [27]

3019

168

15

No statistically significant difference

  1. CPR cardiopulmonary resuscitation, sRCT single-center randomized controlled trial, mRCT multicenter randomized controlled trial
  2. aNumber of clinical centers consisting of the Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium
  3. bNumber of National Health Service ambulance services