Table 1 Characteristics of included studies
From: Prognostic value of capillary refill time in adult patients: a systematic review with meta-analysis
Outcome | Type of adverse event | Time of outcome assessment | Setting | Circulatory failure | Septic shock | Abnormal CRT threshold | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lechleuthner et al. [44] | Adv. events | Uncontrolled bleeding | Hosp. stay | PH | NO | NO | 2 |
Holcomb et al. [37] | Adv. events | Lifesaving intervention requirement | Hosp. stay | PH | NO | NO | 2 |
Pealing et al. [45] | Adv. events | Death due to bleeding | Hosp. stay | ED | NO | NO | 3 |
Ait-Oufella et al. [6] | Vital status | D14 | ICU | YES | YES | 4.9 | |
Mrgan et al. [46] | Vital status | D7 | ED | NO | NO | 3 | |
Van Genderen et al. [8] | Adv. events | According to the Clavien-Dindo classification | D10 | OR | NO | NO | 4.5 |
Hernandez et al. [28] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ICU | YES | YES | 4 | |
Coslovsky et al. [29] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ED | NO | NO | 3 | |
Bourcier et al. [47] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ICU | YES | YES | 3 | |
Alegria et al. [48] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ICU | YES | YES | 3 | |
Lara et al. [49] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ED | YES | YES | 3 | |
Serano et al. [50] | Vital status | D30 | ED | YES | NO | 4.5 | |
Jacquet-Lagreze et al. [17] | Vital status | D90 | ICU | YES | NO | 3.9 | |
Darioli et al. [30] | Vital status | D2 | PH | NO | NO | 2 | |
Jouffroy et al. [16] | Vital status | D38 | PH | YES | YES | 4 | |
Mongkolpun et al. [51] | Vital status | D4 | ED | YES | YES | 4 | |
Bige et al. [52] | Adv. events | Intra-hemodialytic instability defined as a blood pressure drop requiring therapeutic intervention | D0 | ICU | NO | NO | 3 |
Sebat et al. [53] | Vital status | Hosp. stay | ED | NO | NO | 3 | |
Amson et al. [54] | Vital status | D28 | ICU | YES | YES | 3 | |
Magnin et al. [55] | Vital status | D14 | ICU | YES | YES | 3 | |
Morocho et al. [31] | Vital status | D28 | ICU | YES | YES | 3.5 | |
Rossello et al. [38] | Vital status | D30 | ED | NO | NO | 3 | |
Lavillegrand et al. [56] | Vital status | ICU stay | ICU | YES | YES | 3 |
Location | Resuscitation status | Assessment timing | Compression technique | Duration of compression | Stopwatch | Number of measurements | Quality of CRT measurement | Sample size | Mortality rate,% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lechleuthner et al. [44] | finger | Unclear | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 353 | 22% |
Holcomb et al. [37] | finger | Unclear | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 216 | 6% |
Pealing et al. [45] | chest | After | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 20,127 | 5% |
Ait-Oufella et al. [6] | knee | After | D1 | Blanch. nail | 15 | YES | 4 | High | 59 | 37% |
Mrgan et al. [46] | finger | before | D0 | Firm press | 5 | YES | 1 | Low | 1935 | 10% |
Van Genderen et al. [8] | finger | After | D0 | Firm press | YES | 2 | High | 137 | 36% | |
Hernandez et al. [28] | finger | before | D0 | Firm press | 15 | YES | NA | Low | 104 | 31% |
Coslovsky et al. [29] | finger | Unclear | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 8606 | 5% |
Bourcier et al. [47] | finger | After | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 40 | 21% |
Alegria et al. [48] | finger | After | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 90 | 10% |
Lara et al. [49] | finger | After | D0 | Firm press | 10 | YES | 1 | Low | 100 | 14% |
Serano et al. [50] | finger | Unclear | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 212 | 27% |
Jacquet-Lagreze et al. [17] | chest | After | D0 | Piston | 7 | YES | 4 | High | 34 | 29% |
Darioli et al. [30] | finger | before | D0 | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 11,639 | 5% |
Jouffroy et al. [16] | finger | before | D0 | NA | NA | YES | NA | Low | 63 | 36% |
Mongkolpun et al. [51] | finger | After | H6 | Firm press | 15 | YES | 1 | Low | 70 | 41% |
Bige et al. [52] | finger | before | H0 | Blanch. nail | 15 | YES | 4 | High | 211 | NA |
Sebat et al. [53] | finger | before | H0 | moderate press | 5 | NO | NA | Low | 6480 | 36% |
Amson et al. [54] | knee | After | D0 | Firm press | 15 | YES | 1 | Low | 64 | 34% |
Magnin et al. [55] | knee | After | H24 | Firm press | 15 | YES | 1 | Low | 57 | 34% |
Morocho et al. [31] | finger | before | H6 | Firm press | 10 | YES | 2 | High | 175 | 40% |
Rossello et al. [38] | finger | Unclear | NA | NA | NA | NO | NA | Low | 10,979 | 10% |
Lavillegrand et al. [56] | finger | After | NA | NA | NA | NO | 2 | Low | 30 | 33% |