Valve incompetence: a hazard of internal jugular vein cannulation
- Malcolm Watters1
© Current Science Ltd 2000
Published: 14 September 2000
KeywordsCentral venous catheter colour Doppler complication intracerebral venous blood pressure
A competent internal jugular vein valve prevents backward flow of blood when intrathoracic pressure suddenly increases. A competent valve is of theoretical benefit in cardiopulmonary resuscitation (when backward flow would impair the artificial circulation), in patients with critically raised intracranial pressure during positive pressure ventilation and when coughing. This study shows two things. First, cannulation of the internal jugular vein is likely to cause valvular incompetence which is often still present after 3 months. Secondly, 24% of patients presenting for cardiac surgery already have valvular incompetence even before any intervention on their internal jugular vein. The most important question (that the paper does not address) is whether any of this actually matters. I remain to be convinced; particularly in view of the relatively common occurrence of an incompetent valve in patients who do not have internal jugular lines.
Several problems may arise if the internal jugular vein valve is rendered incompetent. Only 90% of humans have such a valve, but there is evidence that puncturing it causes valvular incompetence. The question this study addressed was whether a high approach to internal jugular vein puncture reduced the incidence of internal jugular vein valve damage.
A total of 126 patients scheduled for elective cardiac surgery who had not previously had a central line were recruited
Of these, 24% were later excluded for preexisting internal jugular vein valve incompetence
Patients were randomised to receive either a high approach (1 cm above cricoid cartilage) or a low approach (1 cm below) to internal jugular vein puncture
Colour Doppler ultrasound was then used to assess the blood flow through the internal jugular vein preoperatively, 3-4 days postoperatively before the line was removed, just after removal, and 8 to 27 months later
Incompetence of the jugular vein valve was frequently found postoperatively, 76% with the low approach, 41% with the high approach (statistically significant). This persisted when the catheter was removed (47% low and 28% high). In total, 24 patients still had incompetence at late testing.