Prediction of severe community-acquired pneumonia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Marti, Christophe; Garin, Nicolas; Grosgurin, Olivier; Poncet, Antoine; Combescure, Christophe; Carballo, Sebastian; Perrier, Arnaud

doi:10.1186/cc11447

Critical Care

Table 1 Main characteristics of included studies

From: Prediction of severe community-acquired pneumonia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study first author	Year of publication	Studied scores	End point	Prevalence end point	Uni- versus multicentric	Prospective/Retrospective	Ambulatory/Hospitalized	Number	NTBR	Major criteria excluded
Ananda-Rajah	2008	PSI/CURB-65	ICU admission	10.50%	Uni	R	H	408	Included	n
Angus	2002	PSI/ATS 2001/ATS 1993/URB	ICU admission	12.70%	Multi	P	H	1,339	Included	n
Brown	2009	IDSA-ATS 2007/SMART-COP/CURB-65/SCAP	IT in ICU/IT/ICU admission	12.35%	Uni	R	A+H	2,413	Excluded	n
Buising	2006	PSI/ATS 2001/CURB/CURB-65	ICU admission/death or ICU	6.60%	Uni	P	A+H	392	Included	n
Buising	2007	PSI/CURB/CURB-65/CORB	Vent/vaso ICU	6.30%	Uni	P	A+H	330	Included	n
Calbo	2004	PSI	ICU admission	3.30%	Uni	P	H	362	Included	n
Capelastegui	2006	CURB-65	ICU admission	4.09%	Uni	R	H	1,100	Included	n
Chalmers	2008	CRB-65/CURB-65	Vent/vaso	10.20%	Multi	P	A+H	1,007	Excluded	n
Chalmers	2011	IDSA-ATS 2007/SMART-COP/CURB-65/SCAP/CURB/CRB-65/PSI, ATS 2001 minor	Vent/vaso ICU admission	6.4% 7.6%	Uni	P	H	1,062	Excluded	y
Charles	2008	SMART-COP/CURB-65/PSI	Vent/vaso	10.30%	Multi	P	A+H	882	Included	n
Davis	2010	SMART-COP/SMARTACOP	Vent/vaso	21.00%	Uni	P	H	184	Excluded	n
Escobar	2008	Abbreviated PSI	ICU admission	12.30%	Uni	R	H	6,147	Included	n
Espana	2006	ATS 2001/PSI/CURB-65/SCAP	Death, vent, or septic shock	7.10%	Uni	P	A+H	1,057	Included	n
			Death, vent or septic shock	5.90%	Uni	P	A+H	719	Included	n
			Death, vent or septic shock	11.9%	Multi	R	H	1,121	Included	n
Espana	2010	SCAP/PSI/CURB-65	ICU admission	NA	Multi	R	H	712	Included	n
Ewig	2000	PSI	ICU admission	9%	Uni	P	H	232	Included	n
Ewig	2004	ATS 2001/PSI/CURB/CRB/URB/	ICU admission	16.70%	Uni	p	H	696	Excluded	n
Ewig	1998	ATS 1993/ATS 2001	ICU admission	16%	Uni	p	H	332	Excluded	n
Feagan	2000	PSI	ICU admission	13.60%	Multi	r	H	858	Included	n
Frei	2004	SBP/pH/O₂ saturation/pulse	ICU admission	17%	Uni	r	H	782	Included	n
Fukuyama	2011	IDSA-ATS 2007/SMART-COP/CURB-65/SCAP/PSI/A-DROP	ICU admission Death, vent, or septic shock	7.6% 11.9%	Uni	p	H	505	Excluded	n
Garcia-Vidal	2008	PSI	Early death	2.3%	Uni	p	H	2,457	Included
Garau	2008	PSI	ICU admission	5%	Multi	r	H	3,233	Included	n
Kamath	2003	CURB	ICU admission	10%	Uni	p	H	100	Excluded	n
Lamy	2004	PSI	ICU admission	14%	Uni	r	H	152	Included	n
Liapikou	2009	IDSA-ATS 2007/ATS 2001/PSI	ICU admission	11%	Uni	p	H	2,102	Excluded	n(y)
Man	2007	PSI/CURB-65/CRB-65/ATS 2001	ICU admission	4%	Uni	p	H	1,016	Included	n
Marrie	2007	PSI/CURB-65	ICU admission	10%	Multi	p	H	3,675	Included	n
Neill	1996	CURB	Mortality and ICU	11%	Uni	p	H	251	Excluded	n
Phua	2009	PSI/CURB-65/IDSA-ATS 2007	ICU admission	15%	Uni	p	H	1,017	Excluded	y
Putinati	2003	PSI	ICU admission	10%	Uni	p	H	229	Included	n
Renaud	2007	PSI	ICU admission	3.70%	Multi	p	H	566	Included	n
		PSI	ICU admission	10.50%	Multi	p	H	761	Included	n
Renaud	2009	REA-ICU	Early ICU admission < 3	4.40%	Multi	p	A+H	4,593	Excluded	y
Restrepo	2008	PSI/ATS 2001	ICU admission	19.90%	Multi	r	H	730	Excluded	n
Riley	2004	ATS 2001/PSI	ICU admission	23.69%	Uni	r	H	498	Excluded	n
Roson	2001	PSI	ICU admission	8%	Uni	p	H	533	Included	n
Shah	2010	CURB-65/PSI	ICU admission	23.30%	Uni	p	A+H	150	Included	n
Van der Eerden	2004	PSI	ICU admission	8.00%	Uni	p	H	260	Included	n

A, ambulatory; H, hospitalized; ICU, intensive care unit; IT, intensive treatment; P, prospective; R, retrospective; n, number; y, yes; NTBR, not to be resuscitated; Vent, ventilation; Vaso, vasopressor.

Back to article page

ISSN: 1364-8535

Contact us

Submission enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com