First author (year) | Devices | Methods for assessment | Nonagreement Proportion < 5% | Nonagreement proportion | Overestimation | Underestimation | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ABG | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Stadlbauer V (2010) | Cobas B 221 ABL 800 Grem Premiere 3000 | Clarke error grid | Yes | 0/74 (0%) | 0/74 (0%) | 0/74 (0%) | [15] |
Corstjens AM (2006) | ABL715 | Clarke error grid | No | 178/416 (42.8%) | 178/416 (42.8%) | 0/416 (0%) | [16] |
Hoedemaekers CW (2008) | RapidLab | ISO | Yes | 0/32 (0%) | 0/32 (0%) | 0/32 (0%) | [17] |
Slater-MacLean L (2008) | Chiron865 | Modified error grid | Yes | 1/683 (0.1%) | 0/683 (0%) | 1/683 (0.1%) | [18] |
Kanji S (2005) | RapidLab860 | Within 20% | Yes | 1/115 (0.9%) | 0/115 (0%) | 1/115 (0.9%) | [19] |
Petersen JR (2008) | Rapidpoint405 | Modified error grid | Yes | 0/114 (0%) | 0/114 (0%) | 0/114 (0%) | [20] |
Total | Â | Â | 5/6 (83.3%) | 180/1,444 (12.5%) | 178/1,444 (12.3%) | 2/1,444 (0.1%) | Â |
Gluco-C | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Slater-MacLean L (2008) | SuperStrepFlexx Accu-Chek Inform FreeStyle | Modified error grid | Yes | 24/1,656 (1.4%) | 15/1,656 (0.9%) | 9/1,656 (0.5%) | [18] |
Kanji S (2005) | Accu-Chek Inform | Within 20% | No | 32/118 (27.1%) | 26/118 (22.0%) | 6/118 (5.1%) | [19] |
Petersen JR (2008) | Accu-Chek Inform | Modified error grid | No | 23/114 (20.2%) | 20/114 (17.4%) | 3/114 (2.6%) | [20] |
Desachy A (2008) | Accu-Chek Sensor | Within 20% | No | 41/273 (15.0%) | 12/273 (4.4%) | 29/273 (10.6%) | [21] |
PulziJúnior SA (2009) | FreeStyle | Within 20% | No | 9/38 (23.4%) | 8/38 (21.1%) | 1/38 (2.6%) | [22] |
Lonjaret L (2012) | Contour | Within 20% | No | 75/302 (24.8%) | 8/302 (2.6%) | 67/302 (22.2%) | [23] |
Critchell CD (2007) | Accu-Chek Inform | ISO | No | 53/277 (19.1%) | 44/277 (15.9%) | 9/277 (3.2%) | [24] |
Total | Â | Â | 1/7 (14.3%) | 257/2,778 (9.3%) | 133/2,778 (4.8%) | 124/2778 (4.5%) | Â |
Gluco-A | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Slater-MacLean L (2008) | SuperStrepFlexx Accu-Chek Inform FreeStyle | Modified error grid | Yes | 1/2,048 (0.05%) | 0/2,048 (0%) | 1/2,048 (0.05%) | [18] |
Kanji S (2005) | Accu-Chek Inform | Within 20% | No | 14/113 (12.3%) | 10/113 (8.8%) | 4/113 (3.5%) | [19] |
Petersen JR (2008) | Accu-Chek Inform | Modified error grid | No | 13/114 (11.3%) | 13/114 (11.3%) | 0/114 (0%) | [20] |
Desachy A (2008) | Accu-Chek Sensor | Within 20% | No | 13/232 (5.6%) | n.a. | n.a. | [21] |
PulziJúnior SA (2009) | FreeStyle | Within 20% | No | 3/38 (7.9%) | 3/38 (7.9%) | 0/38 (0) | [22] |
Lonjaret L (2012) | Contour | Within 20% | No | 35/302 (11.6%) | 7/302 (2.3%) | 28/302 (9.3%) | [23] |
Meynaar IA (2009) | Accu-Check Inform | Within 20% | No | 22/239 (9.6%) | 3/239 (1.3%) | 19/239 (7.9%) | [25] |
Total | Â | Â | 1/7 (14.3%) | 101/3,086 (3.3%) | 36/2,854 (1.3%) | 52/2,854 (1.8%) | Â |