Beta-blockers in refractory hypoxemia on venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation: a double-edged sword

Up to 10% of patients admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) suffer from acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) [1]. Severe respiratory failure can result in refractory hypoxemia, characterized by diminished arterial oxygen content and subsequent tissue hypoxia [2]. To address hypoxia, venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (V-V ECMO) can be employed, delivering up to 6–7 L per minute of fully oxygenated blood to the venous circulation [2, 3]. Despite V-V ECMO, persistent hypoxemia may occur [4]. The primary cause of hypoxemia is often limited pump preload, leading to reduced ECMO circuit blood flow (QECMO) [5]. If hypoxemia persists despite increased QECMO, adequate hemoglobin levels, and minimized recirculation have to be ensured. If all these rescue maneuvers failed, some reports propose the utilization of beta-blockers for refractory hypoxemia despite adequate QECMO [4, 6, 7]. However, physiologically, this approach might yield counterintuitive effects as beta-blockers can decrease tissue oxygenation despite raising arterial oxygen saturation (SaO2). We aim to emphasize potential risks associated with using beta-blockers for refractory hypoxemia during V-V ECMO. To begin, the oxygen content in the arterial blood can be estimated by the following formula [8]: arterial oxygen content (CaO2) = (SaO2 × Hb × 1.34) + (PaO2 × 0.003), where CaO2 represents the arterial oxygen content [mL/dL], SaO2 represents the arterial oxygen saturation [%], Hb represents the concentration of hemoglobin [g/dL], PaO2 represents the partial pressure of oxygen in arterial blood [mmHg] and 0.003 is a constant that accounts for the small amount of oxygen dissolved in the plasma. The oxygen present in arterial blood is subsequently conveyed to the tissues by the circulation. Arterial oxygen delivery (DO2) can be therefore estimated by the following formula: DO2 = CaO2 × CO, where CO [L/min] represents cardiac output (CO). DO2 can therefore be improved by increasing either SaO2, hemoglobin levels, or CO. In V-V ECMO, oxygenated blood from the ECMO mixes with deoxygenated blood from the venous circulation thereby increasing SaO2. In most patients with pulmonary failure, QECMO is lower than CO, still providing arterial oxygen saturation up to 100%. Maintaining QECMO/CO > 0.6 is one of the objectives of physicians as it seems to be associated with adequate oxygenation on V-V ECMO [9]. In hyperdynamic circulatory states such as sepsis, CO significantly surpasses maximum QECMO. When QECMO/CO is < 0.6, too much-deoxygenated blood from the circulation mixes with the oxygenated blood returned from the ECMO, resulting in a decrease in SaO2. Therefore, the QECMO/CO ratio is of paramount importance to properly oxygenate arterial blood. In the rare scenario of QECMO/CO < 0.6 at Open Access


COMMENT
Beta-blockers in refractory hypoxemia on venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation: a double-edged sword Dawid L. Staudacher 1* , Tobias Wengenmayer 1 and Matthieu Schmidt 2   Up to 10% of patients admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) suffer from acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) [1].Severe respiratory failure can result in refractory hypoxemia, characterized by diminished arterial oxygen content and subsequent tissue hypoxia [2].To address hypoxia, venovenous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (V-V ECMO) can be employed, delivering up to 6-7 L per minute of fully oxygenated blood to the venous circulation [2,3].
Despite V-V ECMO, persistent hypoxemia may occur [4].The primary cause of hypoxemia is often limited pump preload, leading to reduced ECMO circuit blood flow (Q ECMO ) [5].If hypoxemia persists despite increased Q ECMO , adequate hemoglobin levels, and minimized recirculation have to be ensured.If all these rescue maneuvers failed, some reports propose the utilization of beta-blockers for refractory hypoxemia despite adequate Q ECMO [4,6,7].However, physiologically, this approach might yield counterintuitive effects as beta-blockers can decrease tissue oxygenation despite raising arterial oxygen saturation (SaO 2 ).
We aim to emphasize potential risks associated with using beta-blockers for refractory hypoxemia during V-V ECMO.To begin, the oxygen content in the arterial blood can be estimated by the following formula [8]: arterial oxygen content (CaO 2 ) = (SaO 2 × Hb × 1.34) + (PaO 2 × 0.003), where CaO 2 represents the arterial oxygen content [mL/dL], SaO 2 represents the arterial oxygen saturation [%], Hb represents the concentration of hemoglobin [g/dL], PaO 2 represents the partial pressure of oxygen in arterial blood [mmHg] and 0.003 is a constant that accounts for the small amount of oxygen dissolved in the plasma.The oxygen present in arterial blood is subsequently conveyed to the tissues by the circulation.
Arterial oxygen delivery (DO 2 ) can be therefore estimated by the following formula: DO 2 = CaO 2 × CO, where CO [L/min] represents cardiac output (CO).DO 2 can therefore be improved by increasing either SaO 2 , hemoglobin levels, or CO.In V-V ECMO, oxygenated blood from the ECMO mixes with deoxygenated blood from the venous circulation thereby increasing SaO 2 .In most patients with pulmonary failure, Q ECMO is lower than CO, still providing arterial oxygen saturation up to 100%.Maintaining Q ECMO /CO > 0.6 is one of the objectives of physicians as it seems to be associated with adequate oxygenation on V-V ECMO [9].In hyperdynamic circulatory states such as sepsis, CO significantly surpasses maximum Q ECMO .When Q ECMO /CO is < 0.6, too much-deoxygenated blood from the circulation mixes with the oxygenated blood returned from the ECMO, resulting in a decrease in SaO 2 .Therefore, the Q ECMO /CO ratio is of paramount importance to properly oxygenate arterial blood.In the rare scenario of Q ECMO /CO < 0.6 at maximum Q ECMO , decreasing CO to increase the Q ECMO / CO ratio might appeal as a viable therapeutic target.
Some studies have shown an increase in SaO 2 by betablocker therapy in severely hypoxemic ECMO patients [6,7].However, reducing CO by beta-blocker therapy will increase SaO 2 at the cost of a reduction in DO 2 .Since tissue oxygenation ultimately depends on DO 2 , beta-blocker therapy can aggravate tissue hypoxia, see Fig. 1a.We tested this hypothesis in three mildly hypoxic patients in our ICU using continuous metoprolol infusion (dose 8.7 ± 1.2 mg/h).The average age was 45.5 ± 5.2 years, and the indication for V-V ECMO was ARDS in all patients.Q ECMO and Q ECMO /CO ratio at baseline were 4.3 ± 0.5 l/min and 0.5 ± 0.1, respectively.Beta-blockers For illustrative purposes, recirculation is neglected; a Patient with ARDS and V-V ECMO support.The Q ECMO /CO ratio is 0.67, with saturation at 100%.DO 2 is 500 ml/min.b The same patient with increased oxygen demand, for example, due to infection and fever.Q ECMO remains the same while CO is increased.This results in a ratio of 0.40, saturation of 85%, but a significantly increased DO 2 of 850 ml/min.c Patient with increased oxygen demand treated with beta-blocker.The higher Q ECMO /CO ratio improved arterial oxygen saturation, but the DO 2 drops to 665 ml/min.B Displays three ARDS patients undergoing V-V ECMO therapy, in whom beta-blockers were titrated based on their effects.The measurements were taken three times each after reaching a steady state increased the Q ECMO /CO ratio (0.7 ± 0.1) at the cost of a decrease of CO but also importantly DO 2 , see Fig. 1b.DO 2, oxygen extraction and anaerobic glycolysis (increasing lactate levels) should be monitored closely when beta-blockers are used for refractory hypoxemia on V-V ECMO.Beta-blockers might only be advisable in situations where cardiac output is increased inadequately and not driven by oxygen demand.Targeting mild hypothermia, analgesic treatment, and increased sedative are some examples of simple measures that should be done as first-line treatment to improve Q ECMO /CO ratio.Betablockers should be regarded as therapy for very rare cases, considered only when an increased CO secondary to an increased oxygen demand is excluded.

Fig. 1 A
Fig. 1 A Schematic representation of ECMO flow and cardiac output.Red indicates V-V ECMO flow, and blue indicates cardiac output.For illustrative purposes, recirculation is neglected; a Patient with ARDS and V-V ECMO support.The Q ECMO /CO ratio is 0.67, with saturation at 100%.DO 2 is 500 ml/min.b The same patient with increased oxygen demand, for example, due to infection and fever.Q ECMO remains the same while CO is increased.This results in a ratio of 0.40, saturation of 85%, but a significantly increased DO 2 of 850 ml/min.c Patient with increased oxygen demand treated with beta-blocker.The higher Q ECMO /CO ratio improved arterial oxygen saturation, but the DO 2 drops to 665 ml/min.B Displays three ARDS patients undergoing V-V ECMO therapy, in whom beta-blockers were titrated based on their effects.The measurements were taken three times each after reaching a steady state