Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the patients

From: Effects of endovascular and surface cooling on resuscitation in patients with cardiac arrest and a comparison of effectiveness, stability, and safety: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, year, [reference]

Country

No. of patients

IHCA or OHCA

Cause of cardiac arrest EC/SC

Males, n (%)

EC/SC

Age, years

EC/SC

VF/VT n (%) EC/SC

Flemming,2006 [22]

Germany

80

OHCA

Cardiac/non-cardiac

24(77%)/37(75%)

66 ± 4/61 ± 3

23(74%)/32(65%)

Arrich,2007 [23]

Europe

461

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

N/A

N/A

N/A

Flint,2007 [24]

USA

42

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

17(89.5%)/14(60.9%)

57.2 ± 14.3/54.7 ± 12.2

8(42.1%)/13(56.5%)

Fink,2008 [25]

Germany

49

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

N/A

62 ± 14/65 ± 12

21(80%)/14(61%)

Ferreira,2009 [26]

Netherlands

49

OHCA

Cardiac

16(66.7%)/21(84%)

64.4 ± 11.6/66.9 ± 15.4

22(91.7%)/24 (96.0%)

Gillie,2010 [27]

UK

83

Mixed

Cardiac

29(69%)/34(82.9%)

63.1 ± 13.1/59.6 ± 17.9

21(76.2%)/21(51.2%)

Caulfield,2011 [28]

USA

41

Mixed

Cardiac

18(69%)/12(80%)

63 ± 17/58 ± 15

12(46%)/1(7%)

Knapik,2011 [29]

Poland

41

Mixed

Cardiac

17(85%)/17(81%)

59 ± 11/62 ± 9

N/A

Tomte2011 [30]

Norway

167

OHCA

Cardiac/non-cardiac

61(81%)/76(83%)

56 (39, 69)/59 (47, 69)

51(68%)/69(75%)

Waard,2015 [31]

Netherlands

173

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

75(77%)/55(72%)

67 (58–77)/64 (55–73)

95(97%)/41(54%)

Forkmann,2015 [32]

Germany

63

OHCA

Cardiac

34(85%)/19(81.6%)

63.16 ± 12.05/63.23 ± 11.45

35(87.5%)/22(95.5%)

Oh,2015 [33]

South Korea

360

OHCA

Cardiac/non-cardiac

125(69.4%)/119(66.1%)

55.5 ± 16.6/56.0 ± 17.2

47(26.4%)/38(21.4%)

Rosman,2016 [34]

France

34

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

9(52.3%)/12(70.6%)

64.5 ± 12.8 /64.5 ± 16.5

6(35.3%)/3(18.8%)

Kim,2018 [35]

South Korea

2483

OHCA

Cardiac/non-cardiac

259(68.9%)/492(70.8%)

p = 0.031 N/A

106(28.2%)/566(26.9%)

Sonder,2018 [36]

USA

75

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

30(62.5%)/18(66.7%)

64.3 ± 19.2/53.4 ± 17.8

19(39.6%)/14(51.9%)

De Fazio,2019 [37]

Europe

177

OHCA

Cardiac

N/A

N/A

N/A

Hoedemaekers, 2007 [38]

Netherlands

10

Mixed

Cardiac/non-cardiac

4(80%)/3(60%)

60.4 ± 14.6/58.8 ± 14.7

N/A

Pittl,2013 [39]

Germany

80

Mixed

Cardiac

30(75.0%)/29 (72.5%)

60.4 ± 11.2/63.7 ± 11.4

26(65.0%)/27(67.5%)

Deye,2015 [40]

France

400

OHCA

Cardiac

154(75.9%)/158(80.2%)

60 (49–70)/61 (54–70)

71(34.9%)/74(37.5%)

Look,2017 [41]

Singapore

45

OHCA

Cardiac/non-cardiac

16(69.6%)/19(86.4%)

62.0 (55.5, 68.0)/62.8 (54.0, 67.2)

3(13.0%)/2(9.1%)

  1. Means, standard deviations (SD), or median (interquartile range), frequencies and percentages were used to describe population characteristics, as appropriate
  2. IHCA in-hospital cardiac arrest, OHCA out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, EC endovascular cooling, SC surface cooling, VF ventricular fibrillation, VT ventricular tachycardia