Skip to main content

Table 3 Inclusion overview

From: A systematic review and meta-analysis comparing mortality in pre-hospital tracheal intubation to emergency department intubation in trauma patients

Study ID

Included in crude data mortality analysis RSI

Included in crude data mortality analysis non-RSI/not all RSI

Included in adjusted mortality analysis, RSI

Included in adjusted mortality analysis no/some RSI

Included in mortality analysis, no difference in ISS

Included in mortality analysis, comparable GCS scores below 9

Reason for exclusion

Al-Thani 2014 [27]

Yes

 

Yes

    

Arbabi 2004 [28]

      

Did not meet assessment criteria

Bernard 2010 [29]

Yes

   

Yes

Yes

 

Bochicchio 2003 [30]

Yes

   

Yes

Yes

 

Bukur 2011 [31]

 

Yes

 

Yes

   

Davis 2005 (I) [33]

 

Yes

 

Yes

   

Davis 2005 (II) [32]

      

Conflict with Davis 2005(I)

Eckert 2004 [35]

      

Conflict with Eckert 2006

Eckert 2006 [34]

 

Yes

     

Eckstein 2000 [36]

 

Yes

 

Yes

   

Evans 2010 [38]

Yes

   

Yes

  

Evans 2013 [37]

 

Yes

     

Franschman 2011 [39]

 

Yes

     

Irvin 2010 [40]

 

Yes

 

Yes

 

Yes

 

Oswalt 1992 [41]

 

Yes

     

Shafi 2005 [42]

 

Yes

 

Yes

 

Yes

 

Sloane 2000 [17]

      

Conflict with Davis 2005(I)

Sollid 2010 [43]

Yes

      

Tracy 2006 [44]

 

Yes

     

Tuma 2014 [45]

    

Yes

 

Conflict with Al-Thani 2014

Vandromme 2011 [46]

 

Yes

     

Wang 2004 [47]

 

Yes

 

Yes

   
  1. RSI rapid sequence induction, ISS injury severity score, GCS Glasgow coma scale