Study | Patients, n | Lost to follow-up, n (%)a | Setting/country | Trial duration (mo) | Diagnosis | EN | Inclusion criteria (population) | Exclusion criteria | Intervention | Comparator | Outcomes | UGI bleeding definition |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Control: no prophylaxis | ||||||||||||
Reusser et al., 1990 [11] | 40 | 57/97 (59 %) | Single center/Switzerland | 26 | TBI, ICH | No | Severe acute traumatic or spontaneous hemorrhage intracranial lesion and neurosurgery and MV >48 h | Age <15 yr, GI surgery, PUD, SUP, UGI bleeding | Ranitidine 50 mg IV every 8/6 h titrated to maintain gastric pH ≥4 | No prophylaxis | Overt UGI bleeding, mortality | Bright red bleeding via NG tube, melena, or decrease of blood hemoglobin level >2 g/dl within 24 h associated with a positive stool guaiac test or with gastric drainage of >100 ml of coffee-ground material |
Control: placebo | ||||||||||||
Burgess et al., 1995 [12] | 34 | 0 (0 %) | Single center/United States | 9 | TBI | No | Severe head injury and GCS ≤10 | PUD, GI injury, SUP, oral intake | Ranitidine 6.25 mg/h continuous IV for up to 72 h | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding, mortality | Hematemesis, hematochezia, bright red blood per NG tube or coffee-ground NG tube aspirates, and a 5 % decrease from baseline in hematocrit occurring at least 8 h after study drug initiation |
Chan et al., 1995 [22] | 101 | 0 (0Â %) | Single center/China | 17 | CVD, brain tumor, CNS infection, hydrocephalus | Yes | Nontraumatic cerebral disease and at least two risk factors for UGI bleedingb | UGI bleeding; chronic GI disease; PUD; concurrent heart, lung, kidney, hematological, and liver diseases | Ranitidine 50Â mg IV every 6Â h or 150Â mg PO every 12Â h when starting EN | Placebo | Clinically important UGI bleeding, nosocomial pneumonia | Gastroduodenal bleeding requiring blood transfusions and/or surgery for acute perforated ulcers, lesions confirmed either endoscopically or during abdominal surgery |
Halloran et al., 1980 [13] | 50 | 0 (0Â %) | Single center/United States | 20 | TBI | Yes | Severe head injury and neurological deficits | Apnea and fixed dilated pupils and no motor response, PUD, pregnancy, GI injury, severe hepatic or renal disease | Cimetidine 300Â mg IV every 4Â h for up to 3 wk | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding, mortality | Bright red blood or a 4+ positive stool guaiac test in the gastric aspirate for three consecutive 8-h periods (exclusive of first day after injury), excluding oropharyngeal source of bleeding |
Liu et al., 2013 [16] | 165 | 19/184 (10Â %) | Single center/China | 32 | ICH | No | CT-proven ICH within 72Â h of ictus and neurosurgery, NG tube in place, baseline gastric pH <4, negative GOBT, age >18Â yr | AVM, PUD, facial trauma, anticoagulants, AKI, thrombocytopenia, died within 72Â h after ictus | Omeprazole 40Â mg IV every 12Â h for up to 7Â days, cimetidine 300Â mg IV every 6Â h for up to 7Â days | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding, mortality, nosocomial pneumonia | Hematemesis, aspiration of coffee-ground material from NG tube, or melena, proven by positive GOBT or FOBT, with or without hemodynamic instability resulting from gross bleeding that needed transfusion |
Metz et al., 1993 [14] | 167 | 0 (0 %) | Multicenter/United States | 20 | TBI | No | Severe head injury with 24 h of injury and GCS ≤10, NG tube in place, age >18 yr, expected ICU stay ≥72 h | GI bleeding, severe burns >20 %, AKI, PUD, thrombocytopenia, SUP | Ranitidine 6.25 mg/h continuous IV for up to 5 days | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding, nosocomial pneumonia | • Gastroccult positive NG tube drainage and coffee-ground material for the previous 8 h • Minimum of 50 ml bright red blood per NG tube • Hematemesis in the last 8 h • Hemoccult positive stool • Melena • Hematochezia; with or without endoscopic or surgical confirmation of UGI source of bleeding |
Misra et al., 2005 [15] | 141 | 35/176 (20Â %) | Single center/India | 24 | ICH | Yes | CT-proven ICH within 7Â days of ictus | AVM, coagulopathy, hepatic or renal disease, PUD, anticoagulants | Ranitidine 50Â mg IV every 8Â h | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding, mortality, nosocomial pneumonia | Gross blood, coffee-ground aspirate from NG tube, hematemesis or melena |
Zhang et al., 2014 [28] | 180 | 0 (0 %) | Single center/China | NA | ICH | Yes | CT-proven ICH within 72 h of ictus, age 30–75 yr | Traumatic or brain tumor-related hemorrhage, coagulopathy, PUD, mental disorder or dementia, concurrently included in other clinical trials | Esomeprazole 40 mg/day (n = 36) or lansoprazole 40 mg/day (n = 36) PO, ranitidine 150 mg/day (n = 36) or famotidine 40 mg/day (n = 36) PO | Placebo | Overt UGI bleeding | Clinical evidence of GI bleeding reported, but definition not specified (endoscopy used in all patients at approximately day 21 since SUP) |