Study | Setting | Infusion strategy | Volumes infused during study period (ml) | Minimal value in base excess (mmol/l) | Maximal change in chloride (mmol/l) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Boldt and colleagues [18] | Abdominal surgery | Balanced group | Ā | < 1a | +3a |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 3,866 Ā± 1,674 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified RL | 5,966 Ā± 1,202 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | Saline-based group | Ā | -5a | +8a |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 3,533 Ā± 1,302 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāIsotonic saline | 5,333 Ā± 1,063 | Ā | Ā |
Kulla and colleagues [21] | Abdominal surgery | Balanced | Ā | -1.8 | +3 |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 1,923 Ā± 989 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified RL | 4,268 Ā± 999 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | Saline-based | Ā | -4.2 | +5 |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 1,828 Ā± 522 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified saline | 4,490 Ā± 1,126 | Ā | Ā |
Boldt and colleagues [19] | Cardiac surgery | Balanced | Ā | -1.2 | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 2,750 Ā± 640 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified RL | 5,200 Ā± 610 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | Saline-based | Ā | -4.4 | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130 | 2,820 Ā± 550 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāIsotonic saline | 5,150 Ā± 570 | Ā | Ā |
Boldt and colleagues [20] | Cardiopulmonary bypass | Balanced | Ā | 0a | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.42 | 3,090 Ā± 540 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified RL | 4,010 Ā± 410 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | Saline-based | Ā | -6a | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāā5% albumin | 3,110 Ā± 450 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāIsotonic saline | 5,450 Ā± 560 | Ā | Ā |
Boldt and colleagues [22] | Cardiopulmonary bypass | Balanced | Ā | -1a | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāāHES 130/0.40 | 2,950 Ā± 530 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāModified RL | 5,090 Ā± 750 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | Saline-based | Ā | -5a | Not reported |
Ā | Ā | āāā5% albumin | 3,050 Ā± 560 | Ā | Ā |
Ā | Ā | āāāIsotonic saline | 5,050 Ā± 680 | Ā | Ā |