Skip to main content

Table 3 Performance at admission or a fixed time thereafter.

From: Evaluation of SOFA-based models for predicting mortality in the ICU: A systematic review

Admission SOFA AUC Brier H/C-statistics Compared with AUC Brier H/C-statistics Mort.
Ho et al (2007) [11] 0.791 0.1 C = 7.97 APACHE II 0.858 0.09   H
    p = 0.437 APS 0.829 0.09 C = 2.9 p = 0.890 H
     RPHICU 0.822 0.09 C = 4.7 p = 0.198 H
Holtfreter et al (2006) [12] 0.72    APACHE II 0.785    H
Zygun et al (2005) [14] 0.67   U = 8.8 MODS 0.62   H/C = 10.28 H
    p = 0.38     p = 0.17  
Timsit et al (2002) [15] 0.72   U = 4.55 LODS 0.726   H/C = 10.4 H
    p = 0.8     p = 0.16  
Pettilä et al (2002) [17] 0.776    APACHE III 0.825    H
     LODS 0.805    H
     MODS 0.695    H
Khwannimit (2007) [10] 0.8786    LODS 0.8802    H
     MODS 0.8606    
Gosling et al (2006) [13] 0.61    APACHE II 0.62    I
Zygun et al (2005) [14] 0.67   U = 11.66 MODS 0.63   H/C = 14.29 I
    p = 0.17     p = 0.05  
Moreno et al (1999) [21] 0.772        I
Bota et al (2002) [16] 0.872    APACHE II 0.88    U
     MODS 0.856    U
Ferreira et al (2001) [19] 0.79        I
Janssens et al (2000) [20] 0.82    SAPS II 0.77    H
Other scoring moments AUC Brier H/C-statistics Compared to AUC Brier H/C-statistics Mort.
Bota et al (2002) [16] 48 hours 0.844    MODS 0.834    U
Ferreira et al (2001) [19] 48 hours 0.78        I
Bota et al (2002) [16] 96 hours 0.847    MODS 0.861    U
Ferreira et al (2001) [19] 96 hours 0.82        I
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 2 0.742   U = 11.1 LODS 0.742    H
    p = 0.2      
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 3 0.762   U = 9.94 LODS 0.762    H
    p = 0.27      
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 4 0.766   U = 10.5 LODS 0.766    H
    p = 0.23      
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 5 0.746   U = 13.6 LODS 0.746    H
    p = 0.09      
Pettilä et al (2002) [17], day 5 0.727    LODS 0.76    H
H      MODS 0.744   
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 6 0.763   U = 12.2 LODS 0.763    H
    p = 0.14      
Timsit et al (2002) [15], day 7 0.746    LODS 0.764    H
Bota et al (2002) [16], final 0.897    MODS 0.869    H
  1. APACHE = Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation, APS = Acute Physiology Score (APACHE without chronic health and age condition), AUC = Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve, H = Hospital, H/C = H- or C- Hosmer-Lemeshow statistics, I = Intensive care unit, LODS = Logistic Organ Dysfunction System, MODS = Multiple Organ Dysfunction Score, Mort. = Mortality, RPHICU = Royal Perth Hospital Intensive Care Unit, SAPS = Simplified Acute Physiology Score, SOFA = Sequential Organ Failure Assessment, U = Unspecified (mortality type or H/C statistic).