Skip to main content

Table 1 Peri-operative complications

From: Comparison of two percutaneous tracheostomy techniques, guide wire dilating forceps and Ciaglia Blue Rhino: a sequential cohort study

Complication

GWDF (n = 171)

CBR (n = 171)

P

Conversion to surgical tracheostomy

 

No.

%

No.

%

 

GWDF (n = 6)

CBR (n = 2)

No complications

128

74.9

100

58.5

<0.01

  

Minor complications

       

   Procedure-specific

       

Bleeding (local pressure)

11

6.4

24

14.0

0.04

  

Difficult dilation

0

 

23

13.5

<0.01

  

Difficult procedure

6

3.5

7

4.1

NS

  

Subcutaneous emphysema

2

1.2

2

1.2

NS

  

Cannula insertion difficult

0

 

3

1.8

NS

  

Air leakage cuff

0

 

2

1.2

NS

  

   Procedure-non-specific

       

Puncture endotracheal tube

9

5.3

8

4.7

NS

  

Puncture posterior tracheal wall

4

2.3

2

1.2

NS

  

Accidental detubation

1

0.6

3

1.8

NS

  

Hypotension

1

0.6

2

1.2

NS

  

   Total

34

19.9

75

43.9

<0.01

  

Major complications

       

   Procedure-specific

       

Bleeding (exploration)

6

3.5

4

2.3

NS

2

 

Bleeding (life-threatening)

1

0.6

1

0.6

NS

  

Fausse route

2

1.2

1

0.6

NS

 

1

Oesophageal perforation

1

0.6

0

 

NS

1

 

Cannula insertion impossible

3

1.8

0

 

NS

3

 

Pneumothorax

0

 

3

1.8

NS

 

1

   Total

13

7.6

9

5.3

NS

  
  1. aSome patients had more than one complication. CBR, Ciaglia Blue Rhino; GWDF, guide wire dilating forceps; NS, not significant.