Skip to main content

Table 3 Inter-observer reliability measured by weighted kappa coefficients for each of the three pain tools

From: Psychometric comparison of three behavioural scales for the assessment of pain in critically ill patients unable to self-report

BPS

CPOT

NVPS

Total score

Total score

Total score

0.81 (0.03)a

0.81 (0.03)a

0.71 (0.04)

Facial domains

Face

Face

Face

0.75 (0.03)

0.81 (0.03)a,c

0.70 (0.04)d

Breathing domains

Ventilation/vocalisation

Ventilation/vocalisation

Respiration

0.78 (0.04)a

0.71 (0.05)a,c

0.54 (0.07)e

Muscular domains

Upper limbs

Body movements

Activity

0.61 (0.06)

0.42 (0.07)b

0.52 (0.06)

 

Muscle tension

Guarding

0.43 (0.07)b

0.32 (0.07)b

Physiological domains

 

Physiological I

0.46 (0.08)

Physiological II

0.02 (0.03)f

  1. All data are expressed in weighted kappa coefficient (standard deviation). aP<0.05 compared to NVPS; bP<0.05 compared to BPS; cP<0.05 compared to CPOT muscular domains; dP<0.05 compared to NVPS non-facial domains; eP<0.05 compared to NVPS guarding; fP<0.05 compared to NVPS non-physiological II domains. BPS, Behavioral Pain Scale; CPOT, Critical-Care Pain Observation Tool; NVPS, Non-verbal Pain Scale.