Skip to main content

Table 3 Agreement of blood-glucose monitoring with each device

From: Accuracy of blood-glucose measurements using glucose meters and arterial blood gas analyzers in critically ill adult patients: systematic review

First author (year)

Devices

Methods for

assessment

Nonagreement

Proportion

< 5%

Nonagreement

proportion

Overestimation

Underestimation

Ref

ABG

       

Stadlbauer V

(2010)

Cobas B 221

ABL 800

Grem Premiere 3000

Clarke

error grid

Yes

0/74

(0%)

0/74

(0%)

0/74

(0%)

[15]

Corstjens AM

(2006)

ABL715

Clarke

error grid

No

178/416

(42.8%)

178/416

(42.8%)

0/416

(0%)

[16]

Hoedemaekers CW

(2008)

RapidLab

ISO

Yes

0/32

(0%)

0/32

(0%)

0/32

(0%)

[17]

Slater-MacLean L

(2008)

Chiron865

Modified

error grid

Yes

1/683

(0.1%)

0/683

(0%)

1/683

(0.1%)

[18]

Kanji S

(2005)

RapidLab860

Within 20%

Yes

1/115

(0.9%)

0/115

(0%)

1/115

(0.9%)

[19]

Petersen JR

(2008)

Rapidpoint405

Modified

error grid

Yes

0/114

(0%)

0/114

(0%)

0/114

(0%)

[20]

Total

  

5/6

(83.3%)

180/1,444

(12.5%)

178/1,444

(12.3%)

2/1,444

(0.1%)

 

Gluco-C

       

Slater-MacLean L

(2008)

SuperStrepFlexx

Accu-Chek Inform

FreeStyle

Modified

error grid

Yes

24/1,656

(1.4%)

15/1,656

(0.9%)

9/1,656

(0.5%)

[18]

Kanji S

(2005)

Accu-Chek Inform

Within 20%

No

32/118

(27.1%)

26/118

(22.0%)

6/118

(5.1%)

[19]

Petersen JR

(2008)

Accu-Chek Inform

Modified

error grid

No

23/114

(20.2%)

20/114

(17.4%)

3/114

(2.6%)

[20]

Desachy A

(2008)

Accu-Chek Sensor

Within 20%

No

41/273

(15.0%)

12/273

(4.4%)

29/273

(10.6%)

[21]

PulziJúnior SA

(2009)

FreeStyle

Within 20%

No

9/38

(23.4%)

8/38

(21.1%)

1/38

(2.6%)

[22]

Lonjaret L

(2012)

Contour

Within 20%

No

75/302

(24.8%)

8/302

(2.6%)

67/302

(22.2%)

[23]

Critchell CD

(2007)

Accu-Chek Inform

ISO

No

53/277

(19.1%)

44/277

(15.9%)

9/277

(3.2%)

[24]

Total

  

1/7

(14.3%)

257/2,778

(9.3%)

133/2,778

(4.8%)

124/2778

(4.5%)

 

Gluco-A

       

Slater-MacLean L

(2008)

SuperStrepFlexx

Accu-Chek Inform

FreeStyle

Modified

error grid

Yes

1/2,048

(0.05%)

0/2,048

(0%)

1/2,048

(0.05%)

[18]

Kanji S

(2005)

Accu-Chek Inform

Within 20%

No

14/113

(12.3%)

10/113

(8.8%)

4/113

(3.5%)

[19]

Petersen JR

(2008)

Accu-Chek Inform

Modified

error grid

No

13/114

(11.3%)

13/114

(11.3%)

0/114

(0%)

[20]

Desachy A

(2008)

Accu-Chek Sensor

Within 20%

No

13/232

(5.6%)

n.a.

n.a.

[21]

PulziJúnior SA

(2009)

FreeStyle

Within 20%

No

3/38

(7.9%)

3/38

(7.9%)

0/38

(0)

[22]

Lonjaret L

(2012)

Contour

Within 20%

No

35/302

(11.6%)

7/302

(2.3%)

28/302

(9.3%)

[23]

Meynaar IA

(2009)

Accu-Check Inform

Within 20%

No

22/239

(9.6%)

3/239

(1.3%)

19/239

(7.9%)

[25]

Total

  

1/7

(14.3%)

101/3,086

(3.3%)

36/2,854

(1.3%)

52/2,854

(1.8%)

 
  1. ABG, arterial blood gas analyzer; Gluco-C, glucose meters using capillary blood samples; Gluco-A, glucose meters using arterial blood samples; Ref, reference.