Skip to main content

Table 1 The included studies.

From: Endotoxemia and mortality prediction in ICU and other settings: underlying risk and co-detection of gram negative bacteremia are confounders

Study [reference]

Patient population and location

Numbers of patients with fatal outcome/Number tested

  

Group 1

Group 2

Group 3

Group 4

  

Gnb+

Gnb+

Gnb-

Gnb-

  

Etx+

Etx-

Etx+

Etx-

Pre-defined patient groups: Pediatric

    

Ahmed et al. 2004 [1]

Diarrheal illness, hospitalized

3/9

1/1

1/12

1/19

Casey et al. 1992 [2]

Pediatric cardiac surgery, ICU

0/1

ND

0/15

0/8

Cooperstock, 1985 [3]

Suspected sepsis, hospitalized

0/10

0/1

0/6

0/26

Klein et al. 1988 [4]

Malnourished children, hospitalized

ND

0/1

0/7

0/8

Shenep et al. 1988 [5]

Suspected sepsis, hospitalized

2/9

0/1

1/3

0/13

Pre-defined patient groups: Surgery and peri-procedural

    

Bailey et al. 1976 [6]

Obstructive jaundice, hospitalized

1/1

ND

0/12

0/11

Berger et al. 1995 [7]a

Post-colonoscopy, unspecified location

0/1

ND

0/20

0/11

Foulis et al. 1982 [8]f

Acute pancreatitis, hospitalized

1/1

ND

2/12

1/13

Lau et al. 1996 [9]a

Acute cholangitis, hospitalized

1/8

0/3

0/20

0/9

Lumsden et al. 1989 [10]

Percutaneous biliary drainage, hospitalized

0/1

ND

0/13

0/7

Pre-defined patient groups: Specified infections

    

Brandtzaeg et al. 1989 [11]a

Meningococcal disease, hospitalized

9/24

0/11

ND

0/7

Brandtzaeg et al. 1996 [12]a

Meningococcal disease, hospitalized

21/40

0/19

1/4

3/26

Butler et al. 1973 [13]b

Plague, hospitalized

1/2

ND

0/7

0/1

Butler et al. 1976 [14]b

Plague, hospitalized

0/3

0/2

ND

0/5

Magliulo et al. 1976 [15]c

Salmonellosis, hospitalized

0/1

ND

0/9

0/12

Magliulo et al. 1976 [15]c, d

Typhoid, hospitalized

0/8

0/4

0/1

0/1

Adinolfi et al. 1987 [16]d

Typhoid, hospitalized

0/7

0/7

0/2

0/5

Suyasa et al. 1995 [17]d

Typhoid, hospitalized

1/4

1/6

ND

0/9

Pre-defined patient groups: Oncology and transplant patients

    

Bion et al. 1994 [18]

Elective liver transplantation, ICU

0/1

0/1

1/31

4/19

Engervall et al. 1997 [19]a

Febrile, oncology (80% neutropenic), hospitalized

1/2

0/4

0/4

0/14

Hynninen et al. 1995 [20]

Febrile, oncology (43% neutropenic), hospitalized

0/3

1/24

ND

10/96

Yoshida et al. 1994 [21]a

Febrile, oncology (63% neutropenic), hospitalized

14/21

1/9

11/35

8/71

Pre-defined patient groups: Other

    

Byl et al. 2001 [22]a

Suspected sepsis, hospitalized

2/8

0/4

0/3

1/12

Giamarellos et al. 1999 [23]a

Acute pyelonephritis, hospitalized

1/3

0/9

0/4

0/9

Levin et al. 1972 [24]

Suspected sepsis, hospitalized

14/20

4/14

7/16

27/168

Stumacher et al. 1973 [25]

Suspected bacteremia, hospitalized

6/28

15/37

2/18

4/34

Van Langervelde et al. 2000 [26]a

Febrile hospital admissions, hospitalized

7/24

0/24

9/76

16/324

Adult patients in ICU with sepsis as contemporaneously defined

    

Bates et al. 1998 [27]a

Sepsis syndrome, multi-center cohort, hospitalized

5/10

12/39

42/109

59/198

Billard et al. 1994 [28]

Septic shock, ICU

5/6

ND

1/4

4/8

Danner et al. 1991 [29]a

Clinically defined septic shock, ICU

4/11

0/8

8/32

12/49

Dofferhoff et al. 1992 [30]

Clinically defined severe sepsis, ICU

2/4

0/2

0/6

1/6

Goldie et al. 1995 [31]a

Sepsis syndrome, ICU

5/9

2/3

36/83

18/38

Guidet et al. 1994 [32]a

Sepsis syndrome, ICU

13/24

4/9

14/20

18/40

Strutz et al. 1999 [33]

Sepsis syndrome, ICU

1/5

3/5

5/8

4/10

Wortel et al. 1992 [34]e

Sepsis syndrome, multi-center cohort, ICU

6/8

4/5

2/3

13/25

Opal et al. 1999 [35]

(Low; >20 pg/ml) a, f

Sepsis syndrome, multi-center cohort, ICU

12/51

7/21

78/255

32/128

Opal et al. 1999 [35]

(High; >660 pg/ml) a, f

Sepsis syndrome, multi-center cohort, ICU

21/63

 

84/241

 
  1. aData for these studies [7, 9, 11, 12, 19, 21–23, 26, 27, 29, 31, 32, 35] provided by personal communication; btwo studies of plague were aggregated for this analysis [13, 14]; cthis study stratified into two sub-studies of typhoid and salmonellosis [15]; dthree small studies of typhoid were aggregated for this analysis [15–17]; eonly the patients randomized to receive placebo from this study [34]. fthe mortality proportion data for patients with endotoxemia detected from this study [35] has been stratified at two breakpoints, 20 and 660 pg/ml. Etx, endotoxemia; GNB, Gram negative bacteremia; ND, no data.