Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of the mixed population studies included in the data analysis

From: Survival and neurologic outcome after traumatic out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest in a pediatric and adult population: a systematic review

First author Year Journal N Male/Female Mean
age
Survivors Mortality
%
BT Survivors
BT
Mortal
BT %
PT Survivors
PT
Mort
PT %
Outcome
total
Good Mod Poor Veget
Harner T 1981 The American Journal of Surgery 85    13 78            
Kenneth L 1982 J. Trauma 100    0 100 37 0 100 63 0 100      
Aprahamian C 1985 Annals of Emerg. Medi 95 75/20 29 3 96.8            
Wright S 1989 Annals of Emerg. Medi 47    0 100            
Hoyt D 1989 Arch Surg 48    4 83.3 25 0 100 23 4 82.6      
Lucian A 1992 J. Trauma 207    18 91 27 0 100 180 18 90      
Durham L 1992 J. Trauma 207    18 91.3 27 0 100 180 18 90      
Heinrich H 1992 Z. gesamte Inn. Med. 8    0 100            
Rosemurgy AS 1993 J. Trauma 138 90/48 36 0 100 96 0 100 42 0 100      
Fulton R 1995 Journal American College of Surg. 173    3 98.3            
Quintans-Rodriquez A 1995 Europ J of Emerg. Med 11    2 82            
Falcone R 1995 Air Med J 320 232/88 32.4 6 98.1 284 5 98.2 36 1 97.2 4   2   
Lawhon J 1995 The Journal of Tennessee Med. Assoc. 47 34/13   2 95.7 47 2 95.7     2    1 1
Pasquale M 1996 J. Trauma 106 76/30 41 3 97.2 85 2 97.7 21 1 95.3      
Margolin D 1996 J. Trauma 67 50/17 34 13 81 53 12 77.4 14 1 92.9 13 3 3 5 2
Cocanour S 1997 J. Trauma 11    0 100     11 0 100      
Kuisma M 1997 European Hear Journal 15    0 100            
Stratton S 1998 J. Trauma 879    9 99 382 5 98.7 497 4 99.2 9 3 1 2 3
Battistella F 1999 Arch Surg 604 471/133 36 16 97.4 304 4 98.7 300 2 96.0 16 9   7  
Coats TJ 2001 J. Trauma 39 35/4   4 89.7     39 4 89.7 4 3 1   
MacMillan D 2003 Prehospital Emergency Care 1 1/0   1 100     1 0 0 1   1   
Stockinger Z 2004 J. Am Coll Curg 588 492/96 34 22 96.3 194 12 93.8 341 3 99.1      
Fialka C 2004 J. Trauma 38 28/10 28 4 89.5        4 4    
Pickens J 2005 J. Trauma 184    14 92.4            
Bartolomeo S 2005 Prehosp Emerg Care 29    2 93.2 29 2 93.2     2    2  
Willis CD 2006 Injury 89    4 95 71 3 97 18 2 89 4 4    
Lockey D 2006 Annals of Emerg. Medi 909    68 92.5 542 27 95 114 9 96.1      
O'Brien E 2008 Prehosp Emerg Care 43 36/7 38 0 100 34 0 100 9 0 100      
David, J-S 2007 Crit Care Med 268 210/58 42 6 97.8            
Ashour A 2007 Emerg. Med. Austral. 11    0 100            
Kurimoto Y 2007 Surg. Today 1 1/0 57 1 0     1 1 0 1    1  
Corral E 2007 Resucitation 1 1/0   1 0     1 1 0 1 1    
Whalen W 2008 JEMS 1 0/1 65 0 100 1 0 100         
Franek O 2010 Resucitation 21    1 95.2            
Total    5,391 1,832/525 39.4 238 89.1 2,238 74 96.7 1,891 69 96.4 61 27 8 18 6
  1. BT: blunt trauma; PT; penetrating trauma; Mort: mortality. Good, Mod, Poor and Veget indicate good, moderate, poor and vegetative outcomes.