Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of the mixed population studies included in the data analysis

From: Survival and neurologic outcome after traumatic out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest in a pediatric and adult population: a systematic review

First author

Year

Journal

N

Male/Female

Mean

age

Survivors

Mortality

%

BT

Survivors

BT

Mortal

BT %

PT

Survivors

PT

Mort

PT %

Outcome

total

Good

Mod

Poor

Veget

Harner T

1981

The American Journal of Surgery

85

  

13

78

           

Kenneth L

1982

J. Trauma

100

  

0

100

37

0

100

63

0

100

     

Aprahamian C

1985

Annals of Emerg. Medi

95

75/20

29

3

96.8

           

Wright S

1989

Annals of Emerg. Medi

47

  

0

100

           

Hoyt D

1989

Arch Surg

48

  

4

83.3

25

0

100

23

4

82.6

     

Lucian A

1992

J. Trauma

207

  

18

91

27

0

100

180

18

90

     

Durham L

1992

J. Trauma

207

  

18

91.3

27

0

100

180

18

90

     

Heinrich H

1992

Z. gesamte Inn. Med.

8

  

0

100

           

Rosemurgy AS

1993

J. Trauma

138

90/48

36

0

100

96

0

100

42

0

100

     

Fulton R

1995

Journal American College of Surg.

173

  

3

98.3

           

Quintans-Rodriquez A

1995

Europ J of Emerg. Med

11

  

2

82

           

Falcone R

1995

Air Med J

320

232/88

32.4

6

98.1

284

5

98.2

36

1

97.2

4

 

2

  

Lawhon J

1995

The Journal of Tennessee Med. Assoc.

47

34/13

 

2

95.7

47

2

95.7

   

2

  

1

1

Pasquale M

1996

J. Trauma

106

76/30

41

3

97.2

85

2

97.7

21

1

95.3

     

Margolin D

1996

J. Trauma

67

50/17

34

13

81

53

12

77.4

14

1

92.9

13

3

3

5

2

Cocanour S

1997

J. Trauma

11

  

0

100

   

11

0

100

     

Kuisma M

1997

European Hear Journal

15

  

0

100

           

Stratton S

1998

J. Trauma

879

  

9

99

382

5

98.7

497

4

99.2

9

3

1

2

3

Battistella F

1999

Arch Surg

604

471/133

36

16

97.4

304

4

98.7

300

2

96.0

16

9

 

7

 

Coats TJ

2001

J. Trauma

39

35/4

 

4

89.7

   

39

4

89.7

4

3

1

  

MacMillan D

2003

Prehospital Emergency Care

1

1/0

 

1

100

   

1

0

0

1

 

1

  

Stockinger Z

2004

J. Am Coll Curg

588

492/96

34

22

96.3

194

12

93.8

341

3

99.1

     

Fialka C

2004

J. Trauma

38

28/10

28

4

89.5

      

4

4

   

Pickens J

2005

J. Trauma

184

  

14

92.4

           

Bartolomeo S

2005

Prehosp Emerg Care

29

  

2

93.2

29

2

93.2

   

2

  

2

 

Willis CD

2006

Injury

89

  

4

95

71

3

97

18

2

89

4

4

   

Lockey D

2006

Annals of Emerg. Medi

909

  

68

92.5

542

27

95

114

9

96.1

     

O'Brien E

2008

Prehosp Emerg Care

43

36/7

38

0

100

34

0

100

9

0

100

     

David, J-S

2007

Crit Care Med

268

210/58

42

6

97.8

           

Ashour A

2007

Emerg. Med. Austral.

11

  

0

100

           

Kurimoto Y

2007

Surg. Today

1

1/0

57

1

0

   

1

1

0

1

  

1

 

Corral E

2007

Resucitation

1

1/0

 

1

0

   

1

1

0

1

1

   

Whalen W

2008

JEMS

1

0/1

65

0

100

1

0

100

        

Franek O

2010

Resucitation

21

  

1

95.2

           

Total

  

5,391

1,832/525

39.4

238

89.1

2,238

74

96.7

1,891

69

96.4

61

27

8

18

6

  1. BT: blunt trauma; PT; penetrating trauma; Mort: mortality. Good, Mod, Poor and Veget indicate good, moderate, poor and vegetative outcomes.