|  |  | Total fluid resuscitation during intervention (ml) |  | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Year | Intervention duration | GDT | Control | Difference in mean or median fluid resuscitation (ml) |
Studies of GDT in surgery | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Challand and colleagues [25] | 2012 | Operation | 5,278 | 4,046 | 1,232 |
Cecconi and colleagues [24] | 2011 | Operation + 1 hour | 6,032 | 2,635 | 3,397 |
Mayer and colleagues [35] | 2010 | Operation | 4,528 | 4,494 | 34 |
Jhanji and colleagues [31] without dopexamine | 2010 | 8 hours | 4,892 | 4,351 | 541 |
Jhanji and colleagues [31] with dopexamine | Â | Â | 4,868 | Â | 517 |
Forget and colleagues [28] | 2010 | Operation | 2,394 | 2,918 | -524 |
Benes and colleagues [21] | 2010 | Operation | 3,746 | 3,729 | 17 |
Harten and colleagues [30] | 2008 | Operation | 3,500 | 3,000 | 500 |
Kapoor and colleagues [32] | 2008 | Operation + 8 hours | 330 a | 80 a | 250 b |
Donati and colleagues [27] | 2007 | Operation + 24 hours | 4,391 | 4,285 | 106 |
Lopes and colleagues [34] | 2007 | Operation | 4,618 | 1,694 | 2,924 |
Chytra and colleagues [26] | 2006 | 8 hours | 4,516 | 3,649 | 867 |
Wakeling and colleagues [42] | 2006 | Operation | 5,000 | 4,500 | 500 |
Noblett and colleagues [37] | 2006 | Operation | 3,638 | 3,834 | -196 |
Pearse and colleagues [38] | 2005 | 8 hours | 2,962 | 2,164 | 798 |
McKendry and colleagues [36] | 2004 | 4 hours | 2,020 | 681 | 1,339 |
Gan and colleagues [29] | 2002 | Operation | 5,420 | 4,775 | 645 |
Bonazzi and colleagues [23] | 2002 | Operation to postoperative day 2 | 11,130 | 9,130 | 2,000 |
Venn and colleagues [41] | 2002 | Operation | 2,655 | 2,075 | 580 |
Lobo and colleagues [33] | 2000 | 24 hours | 6,600 | 7,200 | -600 |
Pölönen and colleagues [39] | 2000 | 8 hours | 3,193 | 2,772 | 421 b |
Wilson and colleagues [43] | 1999 | Operation + 12 hours | 3,200 | 3,500 | -300 |
Valentine and colleagues [40] | 1998 | 14 hours preoperative + operation | 8,650 | 6,710 | 1,940 |
Bender and colleagues [20] | 1997 | Operation + 16 hours | 5,137 | 3,789 | 1,348 |
Bishop and colleagues [22] | 1995 | Preoperative and intraoperative | 21,975 c | 10,876 c | 11,099 |
Studies using GDT in surgery comparing restrictive vs. conservative maintenance fluid | |||||
Lobo and colleagues [46] | 2011 | Operation + 8 hours | 3,517 | 5,250 | -1,733 |
Futier and colleagues [44] | 2011 | Operation | 3,380 | 5,588 | -2,208 |
Jammer and colleagues [45] | 2010 | Operation | 3,869 | 6,491 | -2,622 |